logo

Benjamin Lundt Shines as St. Louis CITY Wins First U.S. Open Cup in Penalty Shootout

Reserve goalkeeper Benjamin Lundt became the unlikely hero as St. Louis CITY edged past Columbus Crew in a penalty shootout to claim their inaugural U.S. Open Cup trophy. Lundt’s crucial saves brought excitement to a largely uneventful final and underscored the club’s commitment to a process-driven approach.

Match Overview

For most of the 90 minutes, Columbus Crew dominated possession and pressured the St. Louis defense. This wasn’t the style expected from coach Yoann Damet, who prefers his team to control the ball rather than absorb relentless attacks. Yet, St. Louis stood firm and gradually showed attacking intent in the latter stages. The deadlock persisted through regular and extra time, leading to a tense penalty shootout.

During penalties, Lundt rose to the occasion, saving two shots while all five St. Louis takers converted their attempts. This victory could spark a new era of success for a city rich in soccer history but hungry for trophies.

Team Performances

  • St. Louis CITY: Despite missing star forward Rafa Navarro due to cup tie rules, they displayed resilience. Their midseason squad changes have paid dividends, although creativity up front was limited.
  • Columbus Crew: The side struggled to find a clinical finisher despite creating pockets of opportunity, especially through midfielder Brais Mendez. Their inability to convert chances ultimately cost them.

Key Moments and Players

  • Roman Burki, St. Louis’s starting goalkeeper, was forced off with a head injury, bringing in Lundt who kept the scoreline intact during his time on the pitch.
  • Both teams operated variations of a 3-4-2-1 system, resulting in a cautious, tactical battle with few clear-cut chances.
  • The penalty shootout was a fitting climax, with St. Louis converting all attempts and Columbus faltering twice.

Winners and Losers

Winner: Yoann Damet

As the youngest MLS head coach, Yoann Damet has emphasized team growth over individual glory. His philosophy centers on steady improvement and collective effort. This cup win is proof that his patient approach can yield tangible rewards, bringing the first major trophy to the club.

Loser: Laurent Courtois

Laurent Courtois, serving as interim manager of Columbus Crew, faced challenges including injuries to key players like Wissam Abou Ali. Though he orchestrated an energetic team with solid tactics, his squad lacked a decisive finisher, leaving him short of clinching silverware.

Winner: Benjamin Lundt

The backup goalkeeper emerged as the night’s standout figure. After replacing Burki, Lundt appeared calm and focused, relying more on intuition than detailed penalty analysis. His two crucial saves during the shootout earned him hero status and sealed the victory for St. Louis.

Loser: Rafa Navarro

St. Louis missed the presence of Rafa Navarro, their $12 million signing who scored eight goals in eight MLS games this season. His absence left the attack blunt, highlighting how vital his goal-scoring instincts are to the team’s offensive threat.

Winner: Wilfried Nancy

Wilfried Nancy influenced Columbus Crew’s playing style deeply. His former assistant, Courtois, carries on his tactical blueprint, which emphasizes structured build-up and spatial awareness. St. Louis also reflects Nancy’s philosophy through their sporting director Core Wray. The match illustrated a tactical chess game between two sides shaped by similar coaching influences.

Loser: The Fans

The match proved difficult to watch for spectators craving excitement. Both teams produced just six shots on target combined, and the second half of extra time saw no shots at all. The final resembled a tactical stalemate, lacking the usual MLS unpredictability and attacking flair.