logo

Michael Carrick or Eddie Howe: Who Should Lead Manchester United?

Amid swirling rumors about Michael Carrick's position at Manchester United, Eddie Howe has emerged as a possible replacement. Paul Parker, a former Premier League champion with the Red Devils, shared his views on which manager could better steer the club forward.

Carrick’s Immediate Impact as Interim Manager

After Ruben Amorim was dismissed, Darren Fletcher handed over the reins to Michael Carrick in mid-January. Having enjoyed success as a player with Manchester United, Carrick quickly made his mark. His tenure began with notable wins, including a derby victory against Manchester City and a road win against Arsenal, who were on track to become champions.

A Contract But Questions Remain

Carrick secured a third-place finish last season but faced limited support in the summer transfer window, as United refrained from major spending. This led to concerns about squad depth. So far this season, the team has managed only two wins from nine matches across all competitions and currently sits winless in its last five games.

Pressure is mounting on Carrick, and the board is reportedly considering drastic changes. With Eddie Howe recently leaving Newcastle after nearly five years, speculation grows about his availability and suitability for the role at Old Trafford.

Paul Parker Weighs In: Stay with Carrick

“I still think you’d stay with Carrick,” Parker said during a chat with GOAL in partnership with FreeBets. “I’m no expert, but looking at Eddie Howe, after what he went through with his previous employers, does he want to walk into something similar? He knows he won’t be able to spend freely or bring in his own staff easily.”
“It doesn’t seem like a good fit right now. Everything happening at the top affects the dressing room and the way things are done. It’s not an environment for someone ambitious. If you’re aiming to be a legendary manager by winning the league with United, right now that’s unlikely given the current situation.”
“The club struggles to move players on even after buying more. Players are often content to stay put. Howe will want to work somewhere with ambition. Everyone expects United to compete for the league, but that’s not happening currently. Many people have made bold claims without fully understanding the situation.”

United’s Struggles Continue

Manchester United has not won the Premier League since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013. Off and on the field, there are significant problems to resolve before the club can seriously challenge for major trophies again.

This season, they exited the Carabao Cup early and currently sit 13th in the Premier League after six games, having collected just six points. Their recent 2-0 loss to Atletico Madrid in the Champions League saw tensions rise, with a red card for Leny Yoro and post-match criticism from Lisandro Martinez. Carrick faces intense pressure ahead of a crucial trip to Leeds United on Sunday.

Upcoming Match

  • Fixture: Leeds United vs Manchester United
  • Date: 18 October 2026
  • Competition: Premier League
  • Kick-off: 16:00