Dr Maximilian Pelka on Julian Nagelsmann's Bayern Exit
Julian Nagelsmann’s Bayern exit still stings for one man who watched it unfold from the inside.
Dr Maximilian Pelka, Bayern’s team psychologist from 2021 to 2023, has condemned the way the club hierarchy handled the coach’s sacking in spring 2023, calling into question both the timing and the narrative that grew around it.
A holiday turned into a verdict
Nagelsmann was dismissed in March 2023 while on a short skiing trip during the international break – a break, Pelka stresses, that had been approved by the club. The decision shocked the dressing room and much of Europe, not least because of Bayern’s position in the competitions that matter most to them.
Speaking to kicker, Pelka laid out the context as he saw it.
“The team were in the quarter-finals of the DFB Cup and had just knocked PSG, with Messi, Neymar and Mbappé, out of the Champions League. But Bayern were second behind Dortmund in the league. That brings us to the pressure of expectations. Everyone always wants more, more, more,” he said.
The pressure at Säbener Straße is hardly new. Falling to second place, even in March, can feel like a crisis at Bayern. But for Pelka, that never justified how the club framed Nagelsmann’s brief escape to the mountains.
Club figurehead Uli Hoeneß later suggested that the spontaneous skiing trip played a decisive role in the eventual dismissal. Pelka strongly rejects the idea that a few days away amounted to negligence.
“Exactly the right thing to do”
The sequence was brutal. After a 2-1 Bundesliga defeat to Bayer 04 Leverkusen, Nagelsmann reported to his office at Säbener Straße on the Monday and carried on working as normal. Once the majority of his squad had departed for national team duty, he took his short break.
“He is an adult. I don't need to recommend anything to him,” Pelka said. “But these international breaks give coaches a chance to step off the treadmill for a while. So it was not right to suggest that he had failed to deal with the crisis properly.”
Pelka accepted that the sporting situation was tense, but refused to pin blame on the coach’s decision to leave Munich for a few days.
“Taking three or four days away from the madness to clear his head. With all the national team players away anyway, that was exactly the right thing to do,” he argued.
For Pelka, the logic was simple: a coach under constant fire needs clarity, not permanent proximity to the training ground.
“Of course everyone wants to see you keep working during a difficult period,” he said. “But does that make sense in the end? Or does it make more sense to recharge so you can be fully there again over the following weeks and months? As far as I know, the trip had also been agreed.”
In his eyes, Bayern’s leadership not only changed the coach, they rewrote the story of those crucial days to fit the decision.
From Munich to the national team – and another hard landing
Nagelsmann did not stay unemployed for long. In September 2023, he took over the Germany job at the DFB, seen as a moderniser who could guide a talented but fragile national side into a new era.
The project never fully caught fire. After almost three years in charge, a disappointing 2026 World Cup campaign brought his tenure to an early end. The DFB turned to Jürgen Klopp as his successor, a move that underlined both the scale of their ambitions and the sense that Nagelsmann’s cycle had run its course.
Since that World Cup exit, Nagelsmann has been without a club. His reputation as one of Europe’s brightest coaching minds remains intact, but the scars of how Bayern ended his time in Munich – and how that ending was publicly justified – clearly still trouble those who worked closest to him.
For Pelka, the episode was about more than one sacking. It was a snapshot of modern Bayern: a club where second place in March feels like a scandal, and where even a sanctioned three-day break can be turned into a symbol of failure.






