Eddie Howe: Top Choice for Manchester United if Carrick's Era Ends
Jason Wilcox has identified Eddie Howe as his preferred successor to Michael Carrick should Manchester United decide to act on a dismal start to the season, with the director of football convinced Howe’s deep Premier League grounding puts him ahead of the rest of the field.
Howe, who walked away from Newcastle in late July to take a break from the game, is understood to be ready to listen if United come calling. A sabbatical, yes. Retirement, no. For the right job – and there are few bigger than Old Trafford – he would seriously consider stepping straight back into the heat.
Cost matters too. Howe is currently unattached, and that makes him a more straightforward and cheaper option than Unai Emery, another name admired inside United. Aston Villa would demand around £20m in compensation to release Emery, a figure that weighs heavily in any calculation as Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s regime tries to reshape the club without repeating the financial missteps of the past decade.
Howe’s case: trophies, turnarounds and top-four returns
Wilcox’s admiration is grounded in evidence, not sentiment. In five years at Newcastle, Howe rebuilt a drifting club and left with a modern, hard-running side that had remembered how to compete at the top end of the table.
He delivered the 2025 Carabao Cup, ending a 70-year wait for a domestic trophy on Tyneside and changing the mood music around a fanbase used to false dawns. Before the silverware came the rescue act. Taking over from Steve Bruce in November 2021, with Newcastle winless in their first 14 league games, Howe dragged them to 11th, winning 12 of the final 18 matches. Relegation fears gave way to full stadiums and a sense of direction.
The revival did not stop there. In 2023, he took Newcastle back into the Champions League for the first time in 20 years, then secured qualification again two seasons later, proof that the surge was not a one-off spike. Add five seasons of Premier League experience with Bournemouth from 2015, where he kept a small club punching above its weight, and you have a manager who knows the division’s rhythms and demands as well as anyone on United’s shortlist.
Inside Old Trafford, that matters. After a revolving door of appointments with varying levels of Premier League familiarity, the appeal of a coach who has already rebuilt two clubs in this league is obvious.
Nagelsmann admired, but Wilcox voice carries weight
Julian Nagelsmann, the former Germany and Bayern Munich coach, also has strong support within the new structure. Christopher Vivell, United’s head of recruitment, holds Nagelsmann in high regard and views him as a modern, tactically innovative candidate who fits the long-term project Ratcliffe wants.
Yet Wilcox’s opinion could prove decisive. Ratcliffe controls football policy and has installed Wilcox to shape the sporting direction. When it comes to choosing the next manager, the director of football’s preference is expected to carry significant influence, and right now that preference is Howe.
The dynamic is clear: Vivell’s backing for Nagelsmann keeps the debate alive, but Wilcox is driving the conversation towards a coach who has already shown he can navigate the Premier League’s intensity week after week.
Carrick under strain as results bite
All of this plays out against a bleak backdrop for Carrick. United have opened the campaign with their worst start since 1986, a grim statistic that hangs over every performance and every press conference. Two wins from 11 games have left the 45-year-old exposed, his position openly described as being in the balance.
For now, he stays. Carrick is expected to remain in charge for Sunday’s visit of Bournemouth and is scheduled to hold his pre-match media briefing on Friday. The club has not yet pulled the trigger, but the noise around his future grows louder with each dropped point. Every misstep feels like it could be the one that tips the internal debate towards change.
A club planning big while wrestling with the present
Away from the dugout intrigue, United are also asking supporters to help shape their physical future. The club is inviting fans to give their views on the design of a proposed new 100,000-seat stadium, a project that would redefine their matchday home and the scale of Old Trafford’s footprint.
The survey will go out to season-ticket holders, cup season-ticket holders, executive club members, official members, supporters who have bought hospitality at Old Trafford in the past three years, and those on the season-ticket waiting list. It is a vast consultation, aimed at a fanbase that has long demanded both modernisation and respect for tradition.
So United stand at a crossroads on and off the pitch. A giant considering a new cathedral of football, while behind the scenes the key figures weigh up whether Eddie Howe is the man to lead a new era – and whether Michael Carrick has already run out of time.






