Enzo Maresca Faces Tactical Challenges After City's Premier League Losses
Enzo Maresca walked into the City Ground mixed zone looking less angry than faintly offended, like a man who had followed the manual to the letter only to find the machine still smoking. His team had just lost a third Premier League game in a row after opening the season with seven straight wins. That kind of swing barely exists in English football history; you have to go back to Sheffield Wednesday in 1904-05 to find anything like it.
The numbers, on the surface, offer him a kind of comfort. They also expose him.
City had more of the ball and more shots in all three defeats. At Aston Villa: 63% possession, 15 efforts to eight, and a 2-1 loss. Against Brighton: 62% of the ball, 21 chances to seven, beaten 1-0 at home. At Nottingham Forest: an extraordinary 79% possession, 12 chances to 11, and still they walked away with nothing.
So Maresca can point to the spreadsheets and claim misfortune. Forest, for their part, could counter with the expected goals table, where they arrived third in the league but sat second-bottom in reality. Sooner or later those numbers were going to correct. City just happened to be standing in the way when they did.
There is, though, a statistic that strips away any illusion of bad luck. City have not kept a clean sheet since their win at Anfield after the last international break. Nine games ago. The match before that, they let in three against Sunderland. Seventeen goals conceded in the last eight. That is not a quirk. That is a trend.
Yes, three of those goals owe something to Gianluigi Donnarumma’s errors, but the problem runs deeper than a goalkeeper’s off days. It is structural. It is repeatable. And Forest tore straight through it.
Maresca’s football lives on a high line and a high-wire. His sides want the ball, keep the ball, squeeze the pitch. At Leicester and Chelsea, he was criticised for how cautious his teams could look in possession, endlessly recycling, endlessly probing. But that conservatism had a purpose: protect the space behind a defence pushed right up towards halfway. When you ask your back four to live that high, every turnover becomes a test of nerve and athleticism.
That is why duels matter so much to his model. Lose the 50-50 and you don’t just lose the ball; you lose your protective shield. One missed tackle, one loose touch, and the opposition are running at a back four with grass to gallop into. Do that against a centre-forward in form and you are begging for trouble.
Forest obliged. Liam Delap, a striker who has stumbled through a year and more of frustration, suddenly looked like a man who had rediscovered his craft and found someone to punish. City’s defenders kept offering him the space he craved. He did not need a second invitation.
The damage began higher up. The midfield Maresca selected always looked vulnerable to being outmuscled. Enzo Fernández is a footballer Maresca clearly adores. City paid £125m to prise him from Chelsea, a fee that underlines that faith. On the ball, he is everything a modern coach wants: press-resistant, progressive, inventive. Off it, in Premier League terms, he is not a destroyer.
At Chelsea, when Fernández and Cole Palmer shared a midfield, the team often looked light in the contest. Maresca knew that and tried to solve it with tactical gymnastics, asking Malo Gusto to operate as a strange right-back-cum-No-10 hybrid to plug gaps and keep Fernández on the pitch. The price of artistry was complexity.
City are now paying a similar bill. Rayan Cherki brings outrageous talent between the lines, but he is not a natural defender. Pep Guardiola flagged it last season: his positioning without the ball, his appetite for tracking runners, his physical robustness – all are still developing. When the game opens up, he can be overpowered.
That is manageable if you build the right scaffolding around him. Two mobile midfielders behind, for instance: one shuttler in the Elliot Anderson mould, eating ground and covering channels, plus a holding presence in the Rodri bracket, someone who can read danger and win the first collision. But Rodri has gone. Fernández is not that type. The burden falls heavily on Anderson to do the dirty work for three.
If he is bypassed – if a defender loses the ball high, or a break simply goes around him – City’s shape disintegrates in an instant. What should be a controlled high line becomes a panicked retreat. Forest saw that weakness and drove straight at it.
Maresca did not hide his frustration afterwards. He spoke about duels, about being outfought in the first half, about the need to reassess. He also admitted this was one of those rare moments when a coach is glad not to have another game three days away. The international break gives him time. It also gives him a problem.
He can, in theory, find a tactical solution. He can stiffen the midfield, separate Fernández and Cherki, add an extra runner or a more orthodox holder. He can lower the line a few yards, accept less control of the ball for more control of space. But every adjustment chips away at the identity he has tried to impose.
And the clock is ticking in more ways than one.
It was during the last international break that the independent panel delivered its verdict: City found guilty of all but one of the charges brought by the Premier League. Now, as the league pauses again, there is a strong sense that sanctions could finally be announced.
No one outside the process knows exactly when or how hard the hammer will fall. No one can say with certainty how much that uncertainty is bleeding into performances. Yet it is hard to ignore the possibility that the initial defiance – the “we’ll show them on the pitch” energy – has begun to fade. In its place, perhaps, a duller acceptance. A cloud that never lifts.
That kind of mood seeps into the details. Into the second balls not won, the recovery runs not quite made, the duels lost in the middle third. You can draw the tactical diagrams and tweak the structures, and Maresca will. But when players carry the weight of a looming points deduction, of a season that might be rewritten by an off-field judgment, edges blunt.
So the issue is tactical. It is also mental. It is also existential.
By the time the Premier League returns, City could be staring not just at a title race slipping away, but at a table they no longer recognise. The question for Maresca now is stark: can he fix the system and lift the mood before the numbers – on the pitch and in the courtroom – leave him with nothing left to control?






