logo

Erling Haaland and Man City Stars Could Exit for Free Following Premier League Guilty Verdict, Legal Expert Explains

Manchester City could face a major player departure after the Premier League found the club guilty of multiple financial breaches. According to barrister Paul Gilroy KC, stars like Erling Haaland may have grounds to leave without transfer fees due to employment law protections.

Premier League's Guilty Verdict and Its Impact

The Premier League’s investigation concluded with Manchester City guilty on 114 of 115 charges, including fake contracts with commercial partners from 2009 to 2018. This ruling casts uncertainty over the future of the club’s top players, who might consider their contractual options amid the turmoil.

The club denies wrongdoing and plans to appeal, but the verdict has already raised questions about whether players can terminate contracts early based on loss of trust.

Employment Law and Trust Breach Could Allow Players to Leave

Speaking on the Stick to Football podcast, Paul Gilroy KC explained that every employment contract carries an implied term of mutual trust and confidence. He said:

"If you don’t trust me or I don’t trust you, or if you call me a liar and a thief one day, I can’t work for you the next. That trust is essential."

Gilroy added that a player could claim the club breached this trust, giving them legal grounds to cancel their contract and walk away without penalty.

Rival Clubs Watch Closely as Player Exodus Could Shake Transfer Market

On the same podcast, hosts joked about the possibility of acquiring Haaland on a free transfer, with former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher quipping if the Reds could sign him immediately. Gilroy responded simply, "Yeah, why not?"

Arsenal legend Ian Wright also joked about the striker joining North London, highlighting the potential upheaval in the transfer market if City's squad members are allowed to void their deals.

Appeal Deadline Approaches Amid Off-Field Drama

Manchester City must file their appeal by Friday, with the result determining possible sanctions and the club’s future stability. Meanwhile, coach Enzo Maresca and the players continue to focus on performances amid the off-field uncertainty.

  • Premier League Match: Liverpool vs Manchester City
  • Date & Time: 11 Oct 2026, 18:30