logo

Hansi Flick's Right-Back Dilemma: Fariñas or García?

Hansi Flick stands on the brink of one of those decisions that can define a season. Not a headline-grabbing signing. Not a tactical revolution. A right-back.

It sounds mundane. It isn’t.

The right flank dilemma

Brian Fariñas has kicked the door open. Thrown into a role that is not his natural habitat, he hasn’t just coped; he has excelled. Against Alavés and Aston Villa he played like a man who had been there for years, not weeks. No fuss, no drama, no obvious weakness for opponents to target. Just clean, intelligent defending and the kind of reliability coaches cling to when the stakes rise.

Now, as Atlético loom, the equation changes.

If Eric García recovers in time, Flick must choose between the man in form and the man he trusts. The German’s faith in Eric is absolute. When García is fit, he starts more often than not. Four games out with a muscle problem have not eroded that confidence. If the medical staff give the green light, his chances of walking straight back into the XI are high.

But this isn’t a theoretical exercise. On that side of the pitch waits Álex Baena, constantly drifting, constantly probing, sharp in both body and mind. He is the kind of player who punishes hesitation, who thrives if his marker is half a second slow or half a yard short. And that’s before you factor in the threat of Diego Simeone unleashing pure pace on that flank, stretching the game, forcing one-on-one duels in space.

That is where Fariñas’ candidacy grows stronger. He has shown rhythm, timing, and a capacity to suffer without breaking. He has earned the right to be part of the conversation, not just as a stopgap, but as a genuine option for a major fixture.

Whoever Flick picks also inherits another headache: Ademola Lookman. The winger hasn’t quite rediscovered the explosive heights of last season, yet the danger remains obvious. One run, one cut inside, one shot, and the narrative flips. Coaches know that. Defenders feel it.

Jules Koundé, on paper, would once have been the obvious solution. Not now. His ankle sprain still lingers, and his influence has faded in recent weeks. He looks almost completely out of the running for this role, a third option in name only.

So Flick’s choice on the right is brutally simple: reward Fariñas’ merit, or lean again on García’s hierarchy and experience. Either way, the margin for error against Atlético is thin.

Rodri out, De Jong back, Bernal emerging

The other fault line runs straight through midfield.

Rodri’s injury has arrived at the worst possible time, just as Frenkie de Jong is finally emerging from his own physical issues. Flick has never stopped viewing the Dutchman as a pillar. Even when he couldn’t start him regularly, he kept him close, managed his minutes, and waited.

Marc Bernal, though, has forced his way into the frame with quiet authority. When Rodri went off at the break in the 3-0 demolition of Aston Villa, Bernal stepped in and the structure didn’t wobble. He also got the nod against Paris Saint-Germain in the game Flick chose to rest Rodri, a clear sign of trust in a young player in a high-pressure setting.

De Jong’s recent usage tells its own story. Flick started him against Alavés, but at centre-back, giving Gerard Martín a breather. In the Champions League, De Jong began on the bench before replacing Pedri for the final 20 minutes. Managed, not marginalised.

The pattern from Flick’s career is clear: when the opposition level rises, De Jong usually starts. The coach leans on his calm, his ability to dictate tempo, his capacity to turn a frantic match into something Barcelona can control. That habit could prove decisive now, with Rodri sidelined and the midfield balance under scrutiny.

So Bernal offers logic and continuity. De Jong offers pedigree and big-game experience. Flick must decide whether to reward the emerging option or revert to the man he trusts most when the lights burn brightest.

Attack: Gordon rising, Adeyemi fading

Up front, two pieces are locked in. Lamine Yamal on the right is untouchable, the fixed point of this attack. Raphinha through the middle provides movement, aggression, and a direct line to goal.

The uncertainty lives on the left.

Anthony Gordon is edging ahead of Karim Adeyemi, and not by accident. Flick has repeatedly turned to Gordon when everything is on the line: both clashes with Paris Saint-Germain, the Clasico, the trip to Galatasaray. When the pressure spikes, the coach tends to write Gordon’s name on the team sheet.

There was one exception, at La Cartuja, where Flick went with the German instead. It felt like a nod to rotation, not a reshaping of the hierarchy.

Adeyemi, for now, is paying the price for a brutal run of end product. He hasn’t scored or delivered a decisive assist since 13 October, when he struck Barca’s final goal in the commanding 4-1 win at Galatasaray’s fortress. The raw tools are still there: pace, unpredictability, the ability to beat a man. But football at this level is ruthless. Form matters. Numbers matter.

Gordon, by contrast, has become the safer bet in the biggest games: disciplined without the ball, relentless in his running, sharp in transition. He offers Flick a blend of industry and incision that fits neatly around Yamal and Raphinha.

So the picture is clear but tense. On the right flank, Fariñas fights García for a place in front of Baena and Lookman. In midfield, Bernal and De Jong stand ready to fill Rodri’s void. In attack, Gordon tightens his grip on the left while Adeyemi searches for the spark he has lost since October.

One match against Atlético will not decide a season. But the choices Flick makes now will tell everyone exactly how he plans to navigate the months that follow.