Juventus Seethe Over Controversial Handball Decision in Fiorentina Draw
Juventus walked out of Florence seething, convinced a refereeing decision had stripped them of victory in a breathless 2-2 draw with Fiorentina and left their Serie A climb stalling.
In a match that swung wildly, the controversy arrived right at the end.
A frantic night, a furious finish
Fiorentina twice took the lead, twice were dragged back. Mateo Pellegrino struck first for the hosts, only for Nick Woltemade to haul Juventus level. When Alieu Njie restored the Viola’s advantage, the Stadio Artemio Franchi roared again, but Gleison Bremer powered home to make it 2-2 and tilt the momentum towards the visitors.
Juventus pushed. Fiorentina retreated. The game tightened, then cracked.
In the dying moments, the ball flew into the Fiorentina area and struck Joao Mario on the arm. Juventus players immediately surrounded the referee, screaming for a penalty. The whistle stayed silent. Play went on. VAR stayed out of it.
No on-field review. No trip to the monitor. No spot-kick.
For a side already chasing the pack in Serie A, the sense of injustice hit hard.
VAR under fire
The fallout was immediate across Italy. Leading sports dailies La Gazzetta dello Sport, Tuttosport and Corriere dello Sport all agreed: this, in their view, should have been a penalty.
Former referee and DAZN analyst Luca Marelli dissected the incident in forensic detail. He dismissed the notion that the deflection before the contact made it acceptable.
“The point of contact is below the elbow, more on the arm than in the armpit,” Marelli told DAZN, underlining that the key issue was not just the touch, but the posture. The ball, he noted, had taken a couple of ricochets – Kolo Muani failed to connect properly with a header, then it clipped a boot – yet Joao Mario’s arm remained away from his body.
An unnatural 90-degree angle, Marelli called it.
“There is no doubt the Fiorentina player touched the ball with his arm, and he should have been punished,” he said. Labeling the situation “unexpected” could only ever be one interpretation, Marelli argued; it should not have been the final word. For him, VAR had a clear route: summon the referee to the monitor and let him award the penalty.
That invitation never came. Juventus, instead of lining up from the spot, were left to swallow their anger.
Two goals back, two points gone
On paper, a 2-2 draw away from home after twice trailing speaks to character. In reality, Juventus will look at the table and see damage.
They sit seventh, with 18 points from 11 matches. Not disastrous, but not where a club of their stature expects to be. These are the margins that define a season: a decision here, a missed call there, and suddenly a title push becomes a scramble just to stay in touch.
For Fiorentina, the point feels far more precious. They survived the late storm, escaped the penalty that so many pundits believe should have been given, and held on to move to nine points and 15th place. It is not glamorous, but in their situation, survival and small steps matter.
Juventus, though, cannot afford to think small.
Pressure rising in Turin
The draw in Florence sharpens the focus on what comes next. Juventus need wins, not narratives. They cannot keep applauding their own resilience while the league leaders edge further away.
Converting nights like this into three points is no longer optional; it is the only way their domestic campaign can be rescued. The frustration from Florence will linger, replayed in slow motion on screens across Italy, the still image of Joao Mario’s outstretched arm burned into Juventus minds.
The question now is simple: do they let that moment define their season, or use it to ignite the response their position in the table demands?






