League One Clubs Demand Stricter Spending Limits Amid Financial Crisis
League One’s owners are trying to save themselves from themselves.
Barely half a year after voting through tighter financial rules, a growing number of clubs in the division want to go even harder on spending, pushing for fresh restrictions on how much money can be poured into chasing promotion – or simply survival.
Last summer, League One sides agreed to cut the amount they can spend on squad costs from 60% to 50% of turnover. They also ripped up a staggered approach to owner funding: from now on, only half of any equity injection can go on the playing squad, with the other 50% ringfenced for infrastructure. It was billed as a reset.
Six months on, it looks more like a staging post.
Two new models are now on the table. One would cap the amount a club is allowed to lose over a rolling three-year period. The other would bring in a so‑called luxury tax: any owner investment above a set threshold would trigger a levy, with 50% of that excess cash redistributed to rival clubs. The loss cap is understood to be the preferred option among many in the division.
This push comes at an awkward time. The Professional Footballers’ Association has already launched a legal challenge against the existing rules, arguing in August that clubs breached the terms of their membership of the professional negotiating and consultative committee when they forced through the changes.
It is not the first collision between the EFL and the players’ union. A previous attempt by League One and League Two to impose hard salary caps – £2.5m and £1.5m respectively – collapsed in 2021 after the PFA took the matter to an independent arbitration panel and won. That episode still hangs over every discussion about pay and control.
What has changed is the sense of urgency. The State of the Game report, published last month by the new Independent Football Regulator, jolted boardrooms across the pyramid. Its findings were stark: 94% of clubs in the EFL and National League are losing money, and 32 of the 96 surveyed would not last a month without direct owner funding.
League One is right in the thick of that crisis. Average losses in the division hit £7.5m per club last season, up from £5.3m the year before. Wage spending has continued to balloon despite the new rules; one owner told the Guardian that League One wage bills have already risen by 15% this season alone. The financial arms race is so fierce that a budget which would have secured a top-six finish five years ago would now sit in the bottom three.
That is the backdrop to the latest push for reform. Some owners argue that the clubs have shown, repeatedly, that they cannot be trusted to rein in their own ambition. Regulation, they say, is the only way to stop the division eating itself.
Not everyone agrees on how. Reading and Peterborough have been long-standing advocates of stricter spending controls and see the current moment as an opportunity to lock in deeper change. On the other side stand clubs such as MK Dons and Wycombe, who fear that harsher limits could entrench the gap to the Championship or punish more sustainable models that rely on targeted investment.
The politics are delicate. Any new financial framework would need a two‑thirds majority among League One clubs to be adopted, and there is no clear sign yet that either of the proposed models can reach that threshold.
There is also the question of what happens above them. The Championship relaxed its own rules last season, allowing owners to inject up to £33m over three years as equity without that money counting towards the division’s 85% wages‑to‑revenue limit. One League One source warned that if the third tier tightens while the second loosens, the result could be a “cliff edge” between the divisions – a financial chasm that newly promoted clubs simply cannot cross.
League Two is watching all of this from just offstage. Its clubs are not formally involved in the current talks, but insiders expect that, whatever League One eventually decides, the fourth tier will broadly follow.
For now, the arguments play out in meeting rooms and legal submissions, not on the pitch. The EFL has declined to comment, conscious that any misstep could inflame the PFA dispute or fracture the fragile consensus among its members.
But the numbers are not going away. Nor is the central question: in a division where almost everyone is losing money, who is brave enough to call time on the spending race – and who is prepared to live with the consequences?






