logo

Liverpool Denied Penalty in Arsenal Match: VAR Controversy

Liverpool were denied a penalty they should have had in their 1-0 defeat by Arsenal at Anfield, according to the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel – and the verdict cuts right to the heart of the VAR debate.

Panel says Liverpool should have had spot-kick

The flashpoint came in the 21st minute on 1 November. Bradley Barcola whipped in a cross, Alexander Isak darted across the near post and stretched to meet it. He missed the ball by inches.

Replays showed why.

Jurrien Timber had a firm grip of Isak’s shirt, clearly pulling him back as the Liverpool forward attacked the space. Referee Andy Madley waved play on, and VAR Stuart Attwell checked the incident before clearing it.

Days later, the league’s independent KMI Panel has delivered a blunt assessment: it should have been a penalty.

The five-strong panel voted 4-1 that a spot-kick ought to have been awarded on the field. On the question of VAR intervention, the split was narrower – 3-2 in favour of Attwell stepping in and sending Madley to the pitchside monitor.

At that moment Arsenal were 1-0 up through Kai Havertz. They never needed a second. In a tight game decided by fine margins, the panel’s ruling underlines just how big that missed call was.

‘You have to dive’ – Iraola’s frustration

Isak did not go to ground. He stayed upright, fought to reach the cross and watched the chance slip away. That decision to stay honest dominated Andoni Iraola’s thoughts afterwards.

Speaking to BBC Match of the Day, the Liverpool manager did not hide his anger.

“There is a clear grab of the shirt,” he said. “Alex was just in front of him. He was going to head in front of the goal, but couldn't because he grabbed the shirt.

“If he goes to the floor, they call the penalty, 100%. It should be like this, but it is what it is.

“Next time, the managers should tell Alex to go to the floor, otherwise they won't call it.

“The answer is you have to dive. If you don't dive they won't call it.”

The panel’s majority view backs up Iraola’s argument. Two members pointed to the “subjectivity in assessing impact” as the reason they would not have asked VAR to intervene. The other three went the opposite way, branding the non-intervention a “clear and obvious error”.

What the panel did not support was any escalation beyond a penalty. It unanimously agreed Timber’s foul did not amount to denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity and so did not merit a red card.

Second VAR mistake in as many days

The Liverpool-Arsenal incident was not the only decision to come under scrutiny.

The KMI Panel also ruled that Ipswich should have been awarded a penalty against Hull City on 31 October, flagging a second VAR mistake in as many days.

With the score 0-0 at a corner, Nobel Mendy held back Dara O’Shea in the box. Referee Peter Bankes missed it, VAR Neil Davies stayed silent. Play continued.

Ipswich went on to take the lead shortly afterwards, but Hull fought back and the match finished 2-2. The panel has now confirmed that the original holding offence should have been penalised.

Two games, two missed penalties, two VARs that stayed out of it. The technology is here to clean up the game’s biggest calls. The question, once again, is why it so often watches from the sidelines when it matters most.