logo

Liverpool's Disciplinary Challenges in a Strange Season

Liverpool’s season is starting to read like two different stories bound into one book. On one page: a side that presses ferociously, concedes more fouls than anyone else in the Premier League, and yet still gets told it’s “too honest.” On the other: a team that looks controlled, even cautious, in the league while veering into chaos in the Champions League.

Somewhere in the middle stands Andoni Iraola, trying to make sense of it all before a tricky trip to Selhurst Park.

Top of the table – for fouls conceded

The numbers are stark. Liverpool have conceded 128 fouls in the Premier League this season, more than any other side in the division, according to The Independent. For a team built on intensity and high pressing, that raw aggression is hardly a surprise. But the contrast at the other end of the whistle is harder to ignore.

Only three teams have won fewer fouls than Liverpool. Iraola’s players have been awarded just 88.

The imbalance has sharpened the focus on officiating, especially after back-to-back defeats against Arsenal and Fenerbahce. Against the Gunners, Liverpool were denied a penalty despite Alexander Isak having his shirt pulled in the box, a decision that added fresh frustration to a week already souring.

The issue resurfaced at Iraola’s press conference ahead of Sunday’s visit to Crystal Palace. Not as a rant, not as a conspiracy, but as a puzzle he’s still trying to solve.

“Sometimes too honest”

Iraola did not hide behind the stats. He leaned into them.

“We are quite an honest group, sometimes too honest,” he said, revealing that even the referee had praised his players’ conduct after a recent match. “Even the other day after the game, the referee congratulated us… I'm not sure if I like that or not!

“Our behaviour was very good. I think it has to be genuine; you cannot fake things; it has to be genuine complaints. We are willing, we want to press, we want to be intense – but the balance is that there's a big difference.”

That word – balance – hangs over Liverpool’s entire campaign.

They are physical enough to rack up fouls, clean enough to draw compliments from referees, but not streetwise enough to tilt the fine margins their way. In a title race where every decision matters, that honesty risks becoming a double-edged sword.

A season split in two

The league table offers its own uneasy truth. Liverpool sit fifth, nine points behind leaders Arsenal. Defensively, the record looks solid: nine goals conceded in nine Premier League games. It suggests control, structure, a team hard to break down.

Then you glance at Europe.

Ten goals conceded in just four Champions League matches. The same team, a very different story.

“It's been a strange season,” Iraola admitted. “In the Champions League, we are scoring a lot and conceding a lot. In the Premier League, we are scoring less and conceding less. We obviously want to score more, concede less!”

The contrast is not just about numbers; it’s about personality. At home, Liverpool can look measured, sometimes too measured. Abroad, they open up, thrill, and suffer in equal measure.

Control vs. chaos

For Iraola, the next step is about loosening the handbrake without losing the steering.

“It's a matter of controlling the games,” he said. “Sometimes against Fenerbahce, we're controlling too much, having good positions and arriving but sometimes we have to throw numbers in the box. It will take away more control, yes, but it gives us more threat. Especially against Arsenal… the way we attack the box has to be better.”

That is the tactical fault line he’s trying to bridge. Liverpool can circulate the ball, hold territory, and pin opponents back. What they have lacked in recent weeks is that ruthless flood of bodies into the area, the kind of risk that turns half-chances into goals.

Two defeats have stripped away the cushion of their previous form. The margin for error narrows now.

Gravenberch worry as Palace test looms

Complicating matters is the fitness of Ryan Gravenberch. The midfielder is “touch and go” for Selhurst Park as he continues to manage pain in his heel, a concern for a side that relies heavily on his energy and ability to link midfield to attack.

“A week ago, we were on a run and in a good place and in a better mood,” Iraola said. “Now it changes and it has to be like this. We have to react after two defeats: we need the win against Palace away.”

Selhurst Park is no place for a crisis of conviction. Under the lights, with the crowd tight to the pitch and every challenge roared, Liverpool’s honesty, intensity and discipline will all be tested again.

They lead the league in fouls conceded, trail the leaders in points, and stand at a crossroads in both style and mentality. The next 90 minutes in south London will show whether this “strange season” bends back towards a title challenge or drifts into something far more ordinary.