Could Man City's FFP Case Spark New Super League Debate? Danny Mills Warns Using LIV Golf Example
Man City's Financial Fair Play Case Raises Questions About a Super League Revival
The ongoing Financial Fair Play (FFP) dispute involving Manchester City has reignited debates about spending controls in football. This situation has led some to wonder if talk of a European Super League might resurface. Former City defender Danny Mills shared his views with GOAL, emphasizing why the Super League idea still faces major hurdles. He pointed to the failed LIV Golf venture as a cautionary tale for clubs and authorities considering breaking away from established organizations like UEFA and FIFA.
Super League Plans Met Intense Fan Backlash
In spring 2021, it emerged that a dozen top clubs had agreed to form their own competition, intending eventually to include 20 teams. The Premier League’s “Big Six” — City, Liverpool, Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal, and Tottenham — were among them. Fans reacted strongly against this, leading to the project being abandoned. Still, some clubs, including Real Madrid and Juventus, have not completely discarded the idea.
The biggest challenge for those wanting to break from UEFA and FIFA is that players involved wouldn’t be able to compete internationally for their countries. This would hamper transfer deals and player careers. On the other hand, such a league would remove Financial Fair Play and Profit and Sustainability Regulations, letting clubs with wealthy owners spend freely. At present, Manchester City face 114 FFP charges with possible severe penalties looming.
Why Players Might Reject a European Super League
Asked if City might reconsider joining a Super League amid their current troubles, Mills explained the player perspective: “It’s very, very difficult. To play international football, FIFA must approve your competition. Without FIFA’s ratification, none of those players can take part in international tournaments.”He added that despite the perception players prioritize clubs, representing one’s country in World Cups or European Championships holds unmatched prestige. Winning domestic leagues or even the Champions League may earn club legends fame locally, but World Cup glory grants eternal recognition and honors like knighthoods.
Mills continued: “If I asked who won the Champions League in 2017, most couldn’t say offhand. But you could list all World Cup winners easily. The Super League just won’t gain that kind of significance.”
He also noted past attempts by Saudi Arabia and China to launch similar ventures failed, emphasizing the importance of existing competitions and international football for top players.
LIV Golf as a Warning for Football’s Breakaway Leagues
Other sports have tried independent formats, like LIV Golf, which lured star players with high salaries and new tournament styles designed to attract global audiences. Yet, the project is now bankrupt, seeking fresh investors, showing that new ventures can collapse.
Mills compared LIV Golf’s experience to a Super League: “It hasn’t gone well. They found a short-term workaround that quickly burst. Sport depends on uncertainty, on winning and losing. Fans want fair competition.”
He explained that traditional league systems with promotion and relegation maintain excitement through hope and risk. Without these, games lose meaning, fans lose interest, and seasons become dull. Mills pointed out how the English Football League expanded playoff spots to keep competitiveness alive. A closed Super League without relegation would see teams lose motivation once out of title contention, reducing the quality of matches.
City’s Future Hangs in Balance Amid FFP Appeals
Manchester City await the outcome of their FFP appeal after initial guilty verdicts. Possible punishments include expulsion from the Premier League, points deductions, and transfer bans. This creates uncertainty over the validity of league standings and trophies that season. It remains unclear what penalties will be enforced and how they’ll impact English football.
- Next Match: Manchester City vs Ipswich Town
- Competition: Premier League
- Date: 17 October 2026
- Kick-off: 17:00






