logo

Manchester United's Next Manager: 23 Leading Candidates to Succeed Michael Carrick

After appointing Michael Carrick on an interim basis in January, Manchester United saw a noticeable upswing in performance. His tenure brought more Premier League points than any other manager from his appointment through the end of the season, revitalizing the mood at Old Trafford and securing Champions League qualification. This success led to his long-term appointment.

Yet the start of the 2026/27 season has been challenging. Carrick's side has claimed just one win in six Premier League matches. A notable low point was a 1-0 home defeat to a ten-man Manchester City. Other setbacks include blowing a 2-0 halftime lead against Brighton in the Carabao Cup, losing 3-2 and becoming the first United team in 50 years to lose at home after leading by two goals at halftime. They also squandered a 1-0 lead against ten-man Tottenham Hotspur, who equalised in stoppage time for a draw, and suffered a 2-0 loss to Atletico Madrid. Following the Atletico game, Lisandro Martinez publicly criticised the club’s investment strategy, adding pressure on Carrick.

Odds and Possible Successors

SkyBet have released odds for 23 potential candidates to replace Carrick if results don’t improve. Some names stand out for their past connections or managerial reputations, while others present riskier options.

  • David Moyes (Everton) – 80/1: Once tipped by Sir Alex Ferguson as a perfect fit, Moyes struggled during his previous United spell and is considered an unlikely return.
  • Ange Postecoglou (Al-Nassr) – 80/1
  • Lionel Scaloni (Argentina) – 80/1
  • Roberto Mancini (Italy) – 66/1
  • Ralf Rangnick (Austria) – 66/1: Former interim boss who left after conflicts with the hierarchy.
  • Diego Simeone (Atletico Madrid) – 50/1: Known for defence-first tactics, not a popular guess among fans.
  • Daniel Farke (Leeds United) – 50/1: Has done well with Leeds but lacks experience managing clubs of United’s stature.
  • Brendan Rodgers (Al Qadsiah) – 50/1: Interested in returning to English football.
  • Sebastian Hoeness (VfB Stuttgart) – 50/1
  • Luis Enrique (PSG) – 33/1: Has won consecutive Champions League titles with PSG, boasting a strong track record in European football.
  • Ole Gunnar Solskjaer (Unattached) – 25/1: Former player and interim manager, was a candidate earlier this year.
  • Mauricio Pochettino (USA) – 25/1: Long admired by the club.
  • Roberto Martinez (Unattached) – 22/1: Has Premier League experience but may not excite fans.
  • Darren Fletcher (Man Utd U18s) – 20/1: Likely seen as a stop-gap option.
  • Carlo Ancelotti (Brazil) – 20/1: Recently exited World Cup in Round of 16.
  • Gareth Southgate (Unattached) – 14/1: England manager known for building team culture, but club management would be a new challenge.
  • Unai Emery (Aston Villa) – 14/1: Premier League success with Villa; viewed by many fans as a good fit.
  • Thomas Tuchel (England) – 14/1: Unlikely to leave England before Euro 2028.
  • Kieran McKenna (Unattached) – 10/1: Former United youth coach and assistant, turned down a role recently.
  • Julian Nagelsmann (Unattached) – 13/2: Young, talented, with Bundesliga and World Cup experience.
  • Antonio Conte (Napoli) – 5/1: Known for quick impact at top clubs.
  • Fabian Hurzeler (Brighton & Hove Albion) – 5/1: One of the youngest and brightest coaches in the Premier League.
  • Eddie Howe (Unattached) – 2/1: Favourite; recently left Newcastle and ready for a swift return.

Summary of Odds and Managers

  • 23. Lionel Scaloni - Argentina - 80/1
  • 22. Ange Postecoglou - Al-Nassr - 80/1
  • 21. David Moyes - Everton - 80/1
  • 20. Roberto Mancini - Italy - 66/1
  • 19. Ralf Rangnick - Austria - 66/1
  • 18. Diego Simeone - Atletico Madrid - 50/1
  • 17. Daniel Farke - Leeds United - 50/1
  • 16. Brendan Rodgers - Al Qadsiah - 50/1
  • 15. Sebastian Hoeness - VfB Stuttgart - 50/1
  • 14. Luis Enrique - PSG - 33/1
  • 13. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer - Unattached - 25/1
  • 12. Mauricio Pochettino - USA - 25/1
  • 11. Roberto Martinez - Unattached - 22/1
  • 10. Darren Fletcher - Man Utd U18s - 20/1
  • 9. Carlo Ancelotti - Brazil - 20/1
  • 8. Gareth Southgate - Unattached - 14/1
  • 7. Unai Emery - Aston Villa - 14/1
  • 6. Thomas Tuchel - England - 14/1
  • 5. Kieran McKenna - Unattached - 10/1
  • 4. Julian Nagelsmann - Unattached - 13/2
  • 3. Antonio Conte - Napoli - 5/1
  • 2. Fabian Hurzeler - Brighton & Hove Albion - 5/1
  • 1. Eddie Howe - Unattached - 2/1

All odds are from SkyBet and current as of October 14, 2026.