Manchester City: A Tactical Reset Amidst Uncertainty
The international break has arrived at a useful time for Enzo Maresca. Manchester City’s new era began at full sprint; it now feels like a side catching its breath.
Seven straight wins to open the Premier League season had the Italian framed as the seamless heir to Pep Guardiola. Record-breaking, free-flowing, top of the table. The transition looked almost too smooth.
Then came the jolt.
Three defeats on the bounce have dragged City six points behind leaders Arsenal, who are starting to look every bit like a champion side defending their crown with intent. City, by contrast, suddenly look human.
And all of this is playing out against a heavy backdrop.
The weight of uncertainty
In September, the Premier League found City guilty of breaching financial rules. The club has appealed and continues to play on while awaiting the verdict. The games roll on, but the shadow doesn’t move.
Renowned sports psychologist Dr Paul McCarthy, with a quarter of a century working inside elite dressing rooms in England, Scotland, Germany and France, has seen this kind of tension before.
He talks about players as people first, footballers second. Their personal and professional worlds collide, and when they do, performance becomes “a jigsaw” that needs reassembling.
“Players are like everyone else - they talk about what is going on in their own lives and things that are topical, especially about uncertain events,” he tells BBC Sport.
That uncertainty breeds stories. Rumours. Doubt. And when defeats start to stack up, McCarthy says something more fragile begins to crack: “collective efficacy” – the squad’s belief in its ability to do what it has always done to win.
Because of City’s historic success, that belief has been rock solid for years. Consecutive losses shake it. You can see it in the details now.
City sat top after their flawless start. They are third now, behind Arsenal and Brighton, and the numbers at the back tell their own story.
Before the last international break, the guilty verdict dropped. City responded initially in the way champions do. They went to Anfield, beat 10-man Liverpool, then edged past Ipswich at Etihad Stadium. Crisis? Not yet.
Then the slide: defeats to Aston Villa, Brighton and Nottingham Forest. Defensive cracks, individual errors, and a team that once strangled games now looks vulnerable in transition.
In their first seven league matches, City did not concede a single goal from an individual mistake. Across the last three, four errors have led directly to goals. After 10 games, they have shipped 13 goals – their worst defensive return at this stage since 2008-09.
Asked whether the appeal process and its uncertainty could chip away at focus and attention, McCarthy is clear: “Yeah, that would be a very reasonable human response.
“When people are uncertain about their future, that uncertainty leads to a lack of perceived control, so uncertainty is often more stressful than bad news and the research shows that.
“So while you are waiting and you don't know the outcome, you are uncertain of where you are and there is that lack of control for a lot of people - they come to training, they play their games and it's outside of their responsibility.”
Players can control their runs, their duels, their passes. They cannot control a courtroom.
But the issues on the pitch are not just psychological.
Maresca’s bold shape, exposed
Maresca has never hidden his tactical ideas. While at Chelsea, in a video for NBC Sports, he laid out his approach: a team shifting into a 3-2-2-3 in possession, then pushing one higher to form a 3-1-6. Six attackers, flooding the last line, used to outnumber Inter Milan’s back five.
This season at City, that 3-1-6 is no longer an occasional weapon. It is the default. Maresca has sacrificed a second holding midfielder to add one more attacking midfielder. It is aggressive, front-foot, and built on the belief that his technically gifted squad can live high up the pitch.
On paper, it fits the club’s attacking DNA. On grass, the execution depends entirely on the players asked to carry it.
The spotlight falls sharply on Elliot Anderson and those around him.
Anderson is not a natural sitter. His game is built on intensity, range and physicality. At Nottingham Forest he pressed high and wide, hunted the ball, and joined attacks. This season, with Rodri gone, Maresca and his staff have tried to recast him as the anchor – the player who stays, screens and knits play together.
That transformation takes time. It did for Rodri when he arrived. The difference is that City are now trying to learn on the job while chasing Arsenal.
The experiment itself is not inherently flawed. Elite coaches reshape players all the time. The problem is what has started to appear in the heart of the pitch. City are more exposed through the middle than they have been for years.
Anderson has largely impressed, but he plays to instinct. He steps out of his holding role to press, to track, to win the ball back. Clever opponents have spotted the pattern. They drag him out, bounce a pass around the corner, and suddenly there is space between the lines where once there was a wall.
For Maresca, the core concern is not the 3-1-6 shape in isolation. It is what happens just before it breaks. After the defeat to Forest, he put it bluntly: “You concede transitions when you lose the ball, and when you don't win duels.”
Lose the first ball, lose the duel, and a six-man attack turns into a fragile rest defence very quickly.
A different kind of build-up
The questions do not stop with Anderson.
Behind him, Gianluigi Donnarumma anchors the side. He is a giant of a goalkeeper, but not one renowned for his comfort on the ball. In a system that demands calm, precise build-up from the back, that matters.
The defenders in front of him are competent in possession, but this season their errors under pressure have been punished. Risky passes, poor touches, misjudged decisions when playing out – all have fed opponents who press with conviction.
Guardiola, faced with similar issues last season, moved the creative burden. He asked his midfielders to take control of build-up, dropping deep to collect the ball and carry City into midfield almost single-handedly.
Rodri was central to that. Bernardo Silva, even more so. He would drift back, receive under pressure, twist away from markers and drag City up the pitch on his own.
Both are gone. Their absence has stripped away two of the most reliable escape routes from City’s own third.
As good as Anderson is, he does not yet offer that same guarantee. He is not the one-man press-resistance machine Bernardo Silva was. Ayyoub Bouaddi, though, has shown flashes of that profile. His performance against Brazil’s press at the World Cup hinted at a player who can operate in tight spaces, receive under fire and still find the right pass.
That is the type Maresca may need more of if he wants to keep the 3-1-6 intact without sacrificing control.
Time to reset
So the break comes. City sit third, leaking more goals than they have in over a decade at this stage, operating under the cloud of a financial appeal, and trying to bed in a bold tactical identity without two of their most reliable structural pillars.
Maresca now has what managers rarely get mid-season: time on the training ground and a clear list of problems.
Rebuild the collective belief. Tighten the middle. Decide how much risk this team can really carry with a 3-1-6. Find out whether Anderson can grow into Rodri’s old role, whether Bouaddi can shoulder more responsibility, and how to shield a back line that has started to flinch.
City have lived at the top for so long that any stumble feels like a crisis. This is not that yet. But if the jigsaw stays scattered when the league resumes, how long before the season’s story starts to slip out of their hands?






