logo

Manchester United in Talks with Pochettino as Carrick's Future Hangs in Balance

Manchester United’s season has reached the point of hard decisions and expensive phone calls. In Monaco on Wednesday, the club’s new powerbrokers will decide whether Michael Carrick survives the week. At the same time, they have already started sounding out the man they want if he does not: Mauricio Pochettino.

Monaco summit to decide Carrick’s fate

Chief executive Omar Berrada, director of football Jason Wilcox and co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe are meeting in Monaco for what is officially described as a regular strategy session. This time, the agenda is brutal and simple: what happens next with the head coach.

The expectation inside the club is clear. Berrada and Wilcox are set to recommend that Carrick goes.

Carrick reported for duty at Carrington on Wednesday, cameras catching him driving into the training base while his future was being weighed up more than 800 miles away. He walks into a dressing room marooned in 18th place, winless since August, with just one victory from the first 10 league games.

For a club that built its modern identity on perpetual contention, the numbers are stark. United have not been this low at this stage of a top-flight season since 1986-87, when they sat 20th. Back then, the crisis preceded the arrival of Sir Alex Ferguson. Now, it may yet usher in Pochettino.

United turn again to Pochettino

Manchester United have opened talks with the USA head coach about replacing Carrick, beginning another courtship with a manager they have admired for years but never hired.

They have spoken to Pochettino on three previous occasions about the job:

  • after Jose Mourinho was sacked in 2018
  • in 2022, before appointing Erik ten Hag
  • and again when Ten Hag was dismissed in 2024

Each time, United looked. Each time, they went another way. This time, the pressure of the league table and the impatience of new ownership may force a different ending.

Pochettino, 54, is tied to the USA national team after renewing his contract in August. He has a $10m (£7.5m) release clause written into that deal, a figure United would need to trigger to bring him back to club football.

The timing is awkward. The USA face Haiti over the next week in a two-legged Concacaf Nations League quarter-final, fixtures that shape their immediate competitive calendar. While those games loom, United are pushing ahead with discussions about his potential return to the Premier League.

A familiar face for English football

If United do move, they know exactly what they are getting. Pochettino is no mystery hire.

He first arrived in English football at Southampton in January 2013, quickly turning a solid side into one of the league’s most watchable teams. That spell earned him the Tottenham job in 2014, where he spent five years building a high-energy, high-pressing team that reached the Champions League final and regularly punched above its financial weight.

His work in north London led to Paris. At Paris St-Germain, he managed from January 2021 to July 2022, navigating the demands and egos of a super-club built around star power. Then came a turbulent return to England with Chelsea in 2023-24, a season spent trying to shape an expensively assembled, unbalanced squad into something coherent.

In September 2024, Pochettino stepped into international football with the USA, guiding the co-hosts to the last 16 of the 2026 World Cup. That run underlined his adaptability: from building projects at Southampton and Spurs to managing superstars at PSG, to tournament football with a national team.

Ratcliffe era faces its first big call

Berrada and Wilcox’s trip to Monaco was planned as part of the club’s broader strategic work under Ratcliffe’s part-ownership. But the league table has turned a routine meeting into the first major flashpoint of the new regime.

United must decide whether to persist with Carrick and risk the slide continuing, or pay out on one contract and potentially another to bring in Pochettino. The financial cost is clear: compensation for Carrick’s exit, plus a $10m release clause to prise Pochettino from the USA.

The football cost of hesitation could be higher. United sit in the relegation zone. The mood around the club is heavy. The margin for error is shrinking.

Talks with Pochettino are under way. Carrick is still in the dugout, for now. Monaco will tell United which direction they are really prepared to take.