logo

Manchester United's Troubling Transfer Window: Carrick's Departure and Recruitment Issues

Manchester United’s chaotic summer transfer window has come under fresh scrutiny after it emerged that the club plumped for their seventh and eighth-choice midfield targets before sacking Michael Carrick with the team marooned in the bottom three.

Carrick was dismissed with United 18th in the table, stuck on eight points from their first ten league games. Mauricio Pochettino is expected to be confirmed as his successor, but the story of how the club arrived here runs straight through a muddled recruitment operation and a hierarchy struggling to match its own rhetoric.

Big promises, small delivery

When Sir Jim Ratcliffe bought a minority stake in February 2024, he spoke of building a “best in class” football structure. Supporters, already worn down by two decades of Glazer ownership and the £600m debt that followed their leveraged takeover, clung to that phrase.

What followed this summer hardly matched it.

Carrick, who had guided United back into the Champions League last season and retained broad backing from the stands, went into the window expecting a serious rebuild. He wanted more than he got — specifically a backup striker, a left-back, and a higher calibre of midfielder to replace the fading Casemiro and the failed gamble on Manuel Ugarte.

Instead, he watched as the club lurched through a convoluted process and ended up signing players who, according to The Athletic, sat as low as seventh or eighth on their own shortlist.

A £150m midfield – but not the one they wanted

United spent around £150m on Andrey Santos, Carlos Baleba and Youri Tielemans. On paper, it looked like a substantial refresh. In reality, the club had aimed much higher.

Elliot Anderson was the top target. Behind him on the list: Mateus Fernandes, Sandro Tonali, Aurelien Tchouameni, Alex Scott, Ederson and Ayyoub Bouaddi. The kind of names that suggest ambition, planning, a defined profile.

The players they actually landed told a different story.

The Anderson pursuit became a symbol of the dysfunction. A report on Thursday claimed the England international wanted to join Manchester United. The move never came close. Jason Wilcox, the club’s director of football, is said to have failed to approach anything like the selling club’s valuation. Manchester City then stepped in and paid £116m to get the deal done.

United were left empty-handed on their prime target and scrambling further down the list.

The Tielemans deal carried its own twist. The Athletic revealed United gave serious thought to signing Leon Goretzka as a free agent instead of Tielemans. Goretzka did move to the Premier League — but to Aston Villa, where he replaced Tielemans and promptly scored against United in what proved to be Carrick’s final game in charge. The kind of detail that stings inside any dressing room.

Six signatures, one stalled club

Behind these missteps lies a structure that agents now openly question.

The transfer process at Old Trafford has been described as “complicated”, and not in a flattering way. To get a deal over the line, six different power brokers must be satisfied.

  • Omar Berrada, the CEO.
  • Jason Wilcox, director of football.
  • Christopher Vivell, director of recruitment.
  • Matt Hargreaves, director of negotiations.
  • And above them, the ultimate sign-off from Ratcliffe and the Glazer family.

Agents have reported difficulties simply getting a clear answer. Too many people to convince. Too many loops to close. While rivals move quickly, United bog down in their own bureaucracy.

For a club that once set the pace in English football, this is the new reality: committees, delays, missed opportunities.

Carrick pays the price

On the pitch, Carrick absorbed the impact.

He entered the season with a thin squad in key areas, short of the backup striker and left-back he had requested and relying on midfielders who were never meant to be first-choice options. Results nosedived. Performances sagged. Yet among fans, there was still a sense that the manager was working with tools he had never actually asked for.

When the axe finally fell, sympathy for Carrick was widespread. The feeling that the problems ran far deeper than the dugout had been building for months, if not years.

Pochettino will walk into a club where the banners protesting the Glazers have never really gone away and where Ratcliffe, once welcomed as a potential saviour, now finds his own promises thrown back at him. “Best in class” sounds very different when your marquee summer business is built around seventh-choice targets and a transfer system that needs six signatures to say yes.

The question now is blunt and unavoidable: can United fix the structure that failed Carrick before it swallows another manager whole?