logo

Mauricio Pochettino's Challenge at Anfield

Mauricio Pochettino walks into a storm.

Manchester United’s new head coach has barely signed the paperwork and his first assignment is Anfield, under the lights, against a Liverpool side gathering speed under Andoni Iraola. The timing is brutal. The stakes are worse.

United are 18th after 10 Premier League games. One win – against newly promoted Ipswich Town – five draws, four defeats, 19 goals conceded. This is not a reset from a position of strength; this is a rescue mission. Pochettino’s immediate job is not to chase titles. It is to drag a giant away from a relegation fight.

And he has to start by surviving Anfield.

A new era, same shape?

Michael Carrick is gone, but the structure he left behind might not be. Pochettino has never been a coach who rips everything up overnight, especially before a trip to Liverpool. The most realistic scenario is a familiar 4-2-3-1, a mid-block, and a front line instructed to press in bursts rather than gamble on chaos.

Senne Lammens will be in goal. That, at least, is settled. Everything in front of him is not.

Nineteen goals conceded in ten league games tells its own story. United have been porous, disorganised, and far too easy to run through. Pochettino must decide quickly: trust youth, or lean on the bruised but battle-hardened?

At right-back, Diogo Dalot and Noussair Mazraoui are the established options. In the middle, the temptation to make a statement with Ayden Heaven and Leny Yoro as a youthful pairing is real, especially with the Argentine’s history of backing young defenders. On the left, injuries have stripped things bare. With Luke Shaw out, teenager Harry Amass is the only natural left-back in the squad.

That is the bold route.

The safer call is to throw the responsibility back on the senior players and demand they prove they belong in this “new era”. Harry Maguire, Lisandro Martinez and Matthijs de Ligt are all available as centre-back options, and Pochettino knows that a solid, experienced spine can buy him time. Patrick Dorgu may edge out Amass at left-back, even with his questions defensively, simply because of his physical presence and willingness to surge forward.

The back four he chooses will reveal plenty about his risk appetite on day one.

Midfield first, ideals later

Long term, Pochettino wants his teams to outrun and outlast opponents. High intensity, high fitness, high risk. United are nowhere near that yet. For now, control and security in midfield will matter more than any ideological purity.

Youri Tielemans gives him a steady, reliable base. He recycles possession, rarely panics, and offers enough passing range to connect defence and attack. Alongside him, Kobbie Mainoo is the project: technically sharp, tactically flexible, and exactly the kind of young midfielder Pochettino tends to mould.

Two pivots, both comfortable on the ball, both tasked with protecting a defence that has been exposed too often. That is the starting point.

Ahead of them, the picture is clearer. Bruno Fernandes will operate as the No.10. No coach willingly sidelines his creativity, especially in a team that has struggled to create clean chances. Around him, the choices become more tactical.

On the left, Matheus Cunha looks the likeliest to start ahead of Marcus Rashford. Cunha offers more work off the ball and better combination play in tight spaces, qualities Pochettino values in wide forwards. Central striker is the real decision: Joshua Zirkzee as the focal point, or a more fluid front three?

If Zirkzee leads the line, Bryan Mbeumo is free to attack from his favoured right side, stretching Liverpool’s back line and driving at full-backs. If Pochettino wants Mbeumo central, Amad Diallo could come in on the right, adding trickery and unpredictability in one-on-one situations.

These are not new puzzles. Carrick wrestled with the same combinations and never truly solved them. Pochettino must, and quickly.

One plausible 4-2-3-1 at Anfield looks like this:
Lammens; Dalot, Yoro, Maguire, Dorgu; Tielemans, Mainoo; Diallo, Fernandes, Cunha; Mbeumo.

That is the pragmatic version.

The bolder play: three at the back

But what if he decides that pragmatism is not enough at Anfield?

Pochettino knows the scale of the defensive problem. He also knows what is coming. Liverpool’s attack – Cody Gakpo, Florian Wirtz, Alexander Isak, Bradley Barcola and Rio Ngumoha – is built on pace, rotation and a relentless tempo. Give them space between the lines and they will tear through you.

One answer is to remove the space.

A 3-4-3, with wing-backs dropping into a back five without the ball, would compress the gaps and give United an extra body in central defence. It is not a new idea at Old Trafford. Under Ruben Amorim, United flirted with a similar approach, but Bruno Fernandes suffered, shunted into unfamiliar roles that dulled his influence.

Pochettino may decide to risk it anyway, betting that the structural solidity outweighs the creative compromise. With three centre-backs, Liverpool’s front line has less room to isolate individuals. With wing-backs tracking back, the wide overloads become harder to engineer.

In that scenario, Yoro, Maguire and Martinez could form the back three. Dalot and Dorgu would operate as wing-backs, Mainoo and Tielemans holding the middle. Ahead of them, Mbeumo, Fernandes and Cunha would carry the attacking threat, rotating positions but with clear responsibility to spring forward when United break.

On paper, it would look like this:
Lammens; Yoro, Maguire, Martinez; Dalot, Mainoo, Tielemans, Dorgu; Mbeumo, Fernandes, Cunha.

A system built to absorb, frustrate and then hit on the counter. Not romantic. Potentially effective.

Underdogs at Anfield

Whatever the formation, one truth remains: Manchester United will walk into Anfield as heavy underdogs. Liverpool have momentum, a clear identity and a crowd ready to sense weakness. United have a new manager, a fragile league position and a squad searching for belief.

Pochettino cannot fix everything in one night. What he can do is set a tone. Organisation. Effort. A plan that the players believe in, even if it is not yet perfect.

If United emerge from Anfield beaten but braver, tighter, recognisably coached, it will not change the table immediately. But it might change something more important.

It might mark the night their season finally turns.