Michael Carrick’s Struggles at Manchester United After Crushing Defeat to Como
Michael Carrick's time as Manchester United manager appears to be nearing its end following a humiliating 4-1 defeat to Como in Champions League action. This result adds to a troubling run of poor performances this season, tarnishing the club’s proud legacy in European competition.
The loss has placed Carrick’s position under serious threat. The 45-year-old former United midfielder seemed aware of the gravity of the situation, apologizing to the travelling fans after the final whistle at Lake Como on Wednesday.
What Went Wrong for Carrick This Season?
One of the key issues has been Carrick’s notably passive tactics throughout the 2026/27 campaign, marking a clear change from his interim stint last season. According to MarkStats, last season United ranked sixth in the Premier League for opponent buildup pass completion outside the final third, allowing the team to pressure opponents effectively and disrupt their attacks.
This season, opponents have improved their passing success to 83.1%, dropping United to 14th in the league for that metric. While this doesn’t seem disastrous alone, it reveals that United are letting rivals build up play comfortably without significant challenge.
Moreover, the team’s ability to regain possession in dangerous areas has plummeted. They average only 16.7 opposition turnovers in the attacking third per match, placing them third-worst in the Premier League and ninth-worst among Europe's top five leagues. Simply put, United rarely press or force errors high up the pitch.
Leaking Goals and Defensive Woes
Manchester United’s defense has been alarmingly poor this season. They have managed just one clean sheet, against Azerbaijani side Sabah in the Champions League opener. In seven Premier League matches, they have conceded 10 goals without keeping a single clean sheet. Across all competitions, they've let in two or more goals on six occasions.
Interestingly, United rank fourth-best for the fewest expected goals allowed, suggesting they limit the number of shots on target but often concede high-quality chances. The 4-1 thrashing at Como exposed these defensive frailties once again, making it difficult to see quick improvement.
Lack of Squad Depth Compounds Problems
Carrick’s struggles can’t be separated from the thin squad depth assembled by the club’s executives. Injuries have piled up—Manuel Ugarte is sidelined long-term with an ACL tear, while Marcus Rashford, Luke Shaw, Kobbie Mainoo, Ayden Heaven, Patrick Dorgu, and Lisandro Martinez missed the Como game due to fitness concerns. Benjamin Sesko also faces months out due to injury.
The bench at Como featured players such as Karl Darlow, Tom Heaton, Daniel Armer, Jayden Kamason, Jack Fletcher, Tyler Fletcher, and Tynan Thompson, none of whom saw game time. Those who did enter included Carlos Baleba, Amad Diallo, Joshua Zirkzee, Harry Amass, and Shea Lacey—a lineup far from what a top Premier League club aiming for European glory would field.
New summer signings Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans started but failed to impress, with Tielemans especially criticized for underwhelming displays. Few managers could extract consistent performance from such a squad. Carrick managed last season when fixtures were less congested, but the added European matches this season have pushed him into a tough spot from the outset.
Potential Successors for Carrick
If Carrick is dismissed soon—possibly after upcoming Premier League fixtures against Bournemouth and Chelsea—several names have been suggested as replacements. Eddie Howe, currently unattached since leaving Newcastle in the summer, stands out as a logical choice, though no confirmed reports link him to the role yet.
Other potential candidates include Antonio Conte, Julian Nagelsmann, and Kieran McKenna. Each carries risks: Conte left Tottenham abruptly amid homesickness; Nagelsmann’s experience is solely in Germany and he was recently dismissed from the national team role; McKenna has only managed Ipswich Town and lacks experience at a major club level.
Gareth Southgate has expressed disinterest in returning to club management, while Brighton’s Fabian Hurzeler would be difficult to poach midseason given his current strong start with the Seagulls.






