Michael Carrick: We’ve Lost Our Way but Will Reclaim Our Identity
Michael Carrick walked into the room already knowing what was coming. Seven games without a win, a captain questioning tactics after a 4-1 Champions League humiliation at Como, senior players airing grievances in public, a hierarchy growing restless. At most clubs, that cocktail ends one way.
Carrick chose to fight.
Before a single question was asked, the Manchester United head coach delivered a five‑minute monologue that sounded part confession, part rallying cry, and part reminder of what this club used to be – and what he insists it will be again.
“We’ve lost our way,” he admitted, voice heavy but controlled. “My responsibility is to get a team on a pitch that represents this football club, represents the supporters and they can be proud of it… we’ve gone away from that just recently in certain games, which I’m totally fully aware of and definitely doing something about.”
No divide, no surrender
The obvious question followed. With Bruno Fernandes and Lisandro Martinez having publicly voiced their frustrations over the last fortnight, has the dressing room split?
“It’s not divided,” Carrick said, firmly. “We just need to get back to doing what we do best. And we will.”
There was no smile, no attempt at charm. Just a man under pressure, refusing to distance himself from the mess. If anything, he moved closer to it.
“It is my responsibility what goes on on the pitch,” he said later. “I will hold that umbrella for me to get wet and everyone else to stay dry. That is the privileged position I am in.”
Seven games without a win. United’s worst run since 2015. A 4-1 defeat at Como that he called “really unacceptable”. And yet Carrick keeps putting himself in the firing line.
The Bruno question
The flashpoint of the week came in Italy. After the collapse at Como, Fernandes questioned the tactics used by the United staff. For a captain to do that publicly at a club like this is rare. For it to be seized on so widely by former players tells its own story.
So, would Carrick strip Fernandes of the armband? Drop him? Make an example of his captain?
“The most important thing for me is the team and the dynamics in the squad. It is about the football club,” he replied. “Whatever the situation is I will always do what is best for the football club.”
He would not confirm whether he had spoken directly to Fernandes about the comments. That, he insisted, would stay private. He did, though, reveal he has spoken to the club’s hierarchy, who are understood to be increasingly concerned by the team’s slide.
“It is pretty obvious how we are all feeling,” Carrick said. “The responsibility for me to be in this position is to lead.”
The weight of the badge
If his answers to the Fernandes questions were tight and controlled, his opening statement was anything but. It was raw, emotional, and steeped in the history he believes his players have drifted away from.
“The supporters are a huge part of this football club,” he said, going back to Wednesday night at Como. “For me to see the supporters have to make the effort and the time and spend the money to come and support us on Wednesday and have the feeling after the game, like we all felt, was a tough moment.”
He spoke of identity, of intensity, of the “vigour and enjoyment and passion” United showed in the first five months of his tenure – a period he called “relative success”. That version of United has vanished in recent weeks. He did not try to hide it.
“We haven’t done well enough lately,” he said. “We’re really not happy with [this spell]… we’ve kind of lost our way a little bit if I’m totally honest and we’ll get it back. I’m totally confident we’ll get it back.”
From there, Carrick went deeper, into the values he insists must define the club: humility, hard work, resilience. He name-checked Ryan Giggs, Wayne Rooney, Sir Alex Ferguson, Sir Matt Busby and Sir Bobby Charlton as standard-bearers of a culture he refuses to see eroded.
“Manchester United is always bigger and always has been, always will be bigger than any single individual. Bigger than me, bigger than any of the players and it always has been,” he said.
He talked about Rooney, the club’s record goalscorer, whose “biggest thing was playing for the team, sacrificing for the team and what was good for Manchester United”. About Ferguson, “the best manager of all time”, whose “main priority was Manchester United”. About Busby and Charlton and the way they rebuilt the club from tragedy, based on humility and work.
“We can never lose that and I won’t let us lose that,” Carrick insisted. “Entitlement cannot be at this football club, we’re not entitled to win… it takes hard work, it takes a lot of sacrifice. You’ve got to invest yourself in the football club and you’ve got to do a lot of things that maybe aren’t so nice but you’ve got to do it for each other and you’ve got to win.”
A manager under scrutiny
Strip away the rhetoric and the reality remains brutal. United have not won in seven. Performances have tailed off. The Champions League campaign has hit the rocks. The mood around the club is febrile.
Carrick knows exactly where the spotlight is pointing.
“My responsibility is to get a team on a pitch that represents this football club,” he repeated. “I certainly recognise that we haven’t been doing that.”
He believes the resilience that once defined United still runs through the place. He claims to have “seen it with my own eyes” and to feel “inspired” to live up to it. But belief alone will not quiet the questions if results do not turn quickly.
The next six games will test everything he has talked about.
- Bournemouth at Old Trafford in the Premier League on Sunday.
- Chelsea away.
- Roma at home in the Champions League.
- Aston Villa at home.
- Liverpool at Anfield.
- Another league fixture to follow.
Each one a stage, each one a verdict.
Respect the club. Respect what it takes. Carrick has nailed his colours to that mast. Now he has to show, under the darkest clouds of his tenure so far, whether he can drag Manchester United back towards the standards he spent five minutes preaching.






