logo

Gary Neville criticizes United’s handling of Carrick amid Pochettino appointment

Gary Neville did not bother with diplomacy. He went straight for the jugular.

Manchester United’s treatment of Michael Carrick, he argued, has fallen “well below the standard” of any serious organisation, never mind one that still likes to call itself the biggest club in the world.

Speaking in the wake of Carrick’s departure, Neville painted a picture of a club drifting at the top and floundering over one of its own.

“I think after the Bournemouth game,” Neville said, “I said at the time that Manchester United effectively watched Michael Carrick resign on the pitch at the end of the game with that lap around, that wave goodbye. I think he was expecting it to come at that point and they were indecisive.”

That afternoon felt like a natural end point. Carrick, a Champions League winner and long-serving midfielder, cut the figure of a man who knew what was coming. United’s hierarchy, though, hesitated.

“They obviously felt that they might be able to get to the international break and there could be some sort of pick-up in results,” Neville continued. “But it’s been a difficult two weeks. Indecision, lack of authority, just basically really poor leadership.”

The pressure finally told this week.

United were expected to sack Carrick on Monday. The decision did not arrive until Thursday. In the gap, the club were busy finalising the appointment of Mauricio Pochettino, the former Tottenham and Chelsea manager, to take over at Old Trafford.

For Neville, the timeline is damning. What happened over the last two days, he said, was worse.

“In the last 24-48 hours it’s been spectacularly bad to be in Monaco as an executive and an owner whilst your manager, who’s a club legend, is taking training on the pitch and simultaneously approaching the US Soccer Federation to approach Mauricio Pochettino.”

“It’s just quite simply disgusting. That falls well below the standard of what you would expect in any other business, in any other industry. It would be constructive dismissal and you’d be getting sued.”

The image of owners and executives in Monaco while Carrick worked with the players in Manchester has become a symbol of what Neville sees as a broken culture.

“The optics of being in Monaco whilst the team, the staff, the people who are running the club on a day-to-day basis are in Manchester, it’s just not good and it reflects badly on the leadership.

“I don’t think anybody comes out of this well at all.”

Carrick’s farewell: dignity amid the chaos

If Neville supplied the anger, Carrick brought the grace.

A day after his departure was confirmed, the 43-year-old released a long, heartfelt statement on social media. It read like a love letter to a club he refuses to turn his back on, even after the manner of his exit.

“I’ve had the immense privilege of leading Manchester United, the football club that I love,” he wrote. “There are very few who get to live that and feel it, and for that I’m incredibly grateful.”

Carrick leaned heavily on the themes that shaped his playing career at Old Trafford: responsibility, standards, and the weight of history.

“With that comes huge responsibility, and to be at Manchester United, you need to understand exactly what that means. It’s different to anywhere else.

“Ultimately, you need to push to be the best, but there is a culture, there are values and there are behaviours that you have to live by and respect, which have been built over a long period of time.

“It’s a football club that is unique, with substance and history that cannot be ignored. This is what inspired me every single day.”

If the boardroom has looked distant, the bond between Carrick and the supporters has not.

“I want to say a big thank you to the supporters. I must say, you are a special, rare breed.

“We’ve had some great times this year and moments we’ll all remember. The best thing about being in my position was seeing so many of you lose yourselves in the emotion of those moments, leaving the stadium desperate to come back again next time.

“I just wanted to give you something back. That love never dies.”

He did not hide from recent results, but he made clear what stayed with him most.

“I know we’ve not had the results lately, but you’ve shown me nothing but love and support in times when the easiest thing, and what most end up doing, would be to turn the other way.

“That means more than a win or two. That’s what makes you who you are.

“That’s why I fell in love with this club all those years ago.”

Carrick then turned his attention to the people behind the scenes – the staff, coaches and players who shared the training ground with him through a turbulent spell.

“A special thank you to my coaching staff. You gave me everything you had, every single day, and I couldn’t have asked for any more. I’m incredibly grateful for your loyalty, hard work and support throughout.

“To all the staff behind the scenes, thank you for everything you do for this football club. So much of your work goes unseen, but it never goes unappreciated.

“And to the players, thank you for your efforts and the moments we’ve shared. I wish you all the very best for what’s ahead.”

He closed with a message that underlined why Neville and so many others believe he deserved better.

“I want nothing but success for Manchester United. This club has been such a big part of my life and that will never change. I’ll always be proud to have played my part and I’ll always want the very best for it.

“I’ll be right there with you from now on, watching from the sidelines, cheering the lads on.”

A club in flux beyond Old Trafford

United’s turmoil has dominated an international window that rarely crackles with this much drama.

While Carrick exits and Pochettino prepares to walk into the glare of Old Trafford, Crystal Palace have made their own change, dismissing Pierre Sage and lining up Thomas Frank as the favourite to take charge.

On the pitch, the game does roll on. Wales face Norway later, while Portugal meet Denmark in their first match since Cristiano Ronaldo announced his international retirement. In the WSL, Chelsea host Manchester City in the standout fixture of four games today.

The calendar is full. The noise around Manchester United is louder.

The question now is whether the new man can restore the standards Neville insists have been lost – or whether Carrick’s dignified farewell becomes another chapter in a story of a giant that keeps tripping over its own feet.