logo

Newcastle United's Struggles: From Glory to Hard Times

On Tuesday, Newcastle United’s social media team reached for nostalgia. A clip, a caption, and a reminder: three decades since Kevin Keegan’s fearless entertainers dismantled Manchester United 5-0 at St James’ Park and sat on top of the Premier League.

It was a jolt of black-and-white joy. A reminder of what this club once looked like at full throttle.

It also arrived in the same week their new German head coach, Matthias Jaissle, is still working out why his Newcastle side of 2026-27 look anything but.

Three defeats in four, boos at St James’ Park, and a season that already feels edgy rather than exciting. On Sunday, away at struggling Crystal Palace at Selhurst Park, Newcastle are not chasing momentum. They are trying to stop the slide.

“The pressure will seriously be on if they don't get a result at Palace,” says Charlotte Robson from the True Faith Newcastle United podcast. That pressure is already humming in the background. Lose again, and it starts to roar.

From Howe’s high to a hard reset

This is the hangover after five years of Eddie Howe. Five years that delivered a clear identity, European nights and, crucially, the club’s first major domestic trophy since 1955. That era ended in July. The reset has been brutal.

Anthony Gordon sold to Barcelona for more than £69m. Sandro Tonali to Tottenham in a deal worth up to £100m. A week later, Bruno Guimaraes to Arsenal for £75m. England defender Kieran Trippier, 36, gone as well.

Alan Shearer saw it coming.

“Speaking purely as a fan, I think we have to get ready for a tough season and some very challenging times ahead,” he told BBC Sport after Howe stepped down. He then delivered the line that now hangs over this campaign: “You cannot keep on selling your best players and then hope to be in contention at the top of the table.”

Seven games in, Newcastle sit on eight points. Two wins – away at Tottenham and at home to newly promoted Hull City – and not much else to cling to. Shearer’s warning is playing out in real time.

Rory Smith, football correspondent of the Observer, joined the dots on BBC Radio 5 Live’s The Monday Night Club. “If you had said at the end of last season Newcastle would lose Gordon, Guimaraes, Tonali and Howe, you would probably get this [eight points from seven games],” he said.

The club didn’t just change players. It changed its spine, its voice, its direction.

Youth, money and a team still half-built

Newcastle spent about £250m in the summer. On paper, that sounds like a statement. Look closer and it reads like a long-term gamble.

Most of the signings are 21 or under. Bazoumana Toure, the Ivory Coast winger, and French midfielder Aladji Bamba have yet to start a Premier League game despite being fit and available. Another teenager, 18-year-old Sean Steur, caught the eye when he started against Hull in September. He has not played a minute since.

“The profile of the players Newcastle signed in the summer, and it may well bear fruit in time... they went very young and relatively inexperienced,” says Smith. “They didn't go out and sign a load of established Premier League players.”

This is a squad built with tomorrow in mind. The problem is that the questions are arriving today.

Up front, the issues run deep. Alexander Isak left for Liverpool in a British record £125m deal almost 14 months ago and has not been properly replaced. There is an argument they never truly replaced Callum Wilson either; he left in the same summer as Isak.

Yoane Wissa was brought in as Wilson’s successor, Nick Woltemade as the Isak replacement. Woltemade, signed in a club-record deal worth up to £69m in August 2025, is now on loan at Juventus. Wissa has struggled for rhythm since returning from injury.

The result? A team that looks blunt where it once looked ruthless.

A chaotic edge under Jaissle

Jaissle arrived with pedigree. Newcastle paid Al-Ahli £9.5m in compensation to bring in the coach who had just delivered consecutive Asian Champions League titles. Before that, he built a strong reputation at Red Bull Salzburg in Austria.

Expectations were high when the 38-year-old landed on Tyneside shortly before the season. Seventy-nine days later, he still feels like a coach in transition, caught between what he wants this team to be and what it currently is.

Supporters talk about a lack of identity. The data backs up the unease.

Newcastle have not kept a home clean sheet in 16 games in all competitions, the longest such run in their history. In the league, they are conceding an average of two goals per game; only Crystal Palace (17) and Ipswich (15) have let in more than Newcastle’s 14.

At the other end, the picture is just as worrying. Against Aston Villa last weekend, they managed a single shot on target – their lowest tally in a Premier League home match since August 2024. That effort came from centre-back Sven Botman. When Jaissle turned to his bench, he ended up pushing another centre-back, Dan Burn, into a forward role as a substitute.

It looked desperate. It looked disjointed.

Chris Sutton, watching that Villa defeat for BBC Radio 5 Live, did not like what he saw. Newcastle, he said, look “chaotic” under Jaissle. “There is not enough in the final third in terms of creativity and they have a vulnerability at the back,” he added. “Newcastle fans have every right to be a little bit concerned. They didn't look like scoring against Villa and that is what really concerns Newcastle fans.”

Former defender John Anderson also senses a rigidity. “One result can change a lot – all it needs is one good win and all of a sudden you're back on track – but Matthias Jaissle seems very set in his ways at this moment in time,” he told BBC Sport.

Aggressive, attacking football was the promise in pre-season interviews. “We are not there yet, we're still working it out,” admits Robson. The gap between the rhetoric and the reality is growing harder to ignore.

Calm at the top, questions in the stands

Inside the club, nobody is reaching for the panic button. Chief executive David Hopkinson and sporting director Ross Wilson are projecting calm. Jaissle is expected to be given time. A muddled start is not a crisis, they insist.

Robson believes patience is required after a summer of upheaval. She is not alone. There is an understanding that ripping out key players and a long-serving manager comes with a cost.

But patience in football is always conditional. It lasts as long as the league table allows.

Right now, Newcastle sit in that awkward middle ground. Not in freefall, not in control. Just stuck. Eight points from seven games. No clean sheets at home. A team that looks unsure of itself in both boxes.

The fixture list is not about to ease the strain. After Sunday’s trip to Palace, Newcastle visit Everton in the last-16 of the Carabao Cup next Thursday, then host Everton in the league on 2 November before travelling to Fulham five days later. Jaissle will not want to hit the next international break without a win in six league and cup games.

“There are more questions being asked now,” says Robson. The questions are not yet about sackings or ultimatums. They are about direction, conviction, and whether this expensive, youthful rebuild has left the team short of battle-hardened leaders.

Selhurst as a crossroads

So to Selhurst Park, and a match that carries more weight than the table alone suggests.

Crystal Palace are struggling, but so are Newcastle. One side is fighting to climb away from the bottom, the other to prove it still belongs in the conversation near the top. For Jaissle, it is not just about three points. It is about evidence – proof that his Newcastle can look like a coherent Premier League side rather than an experiment in progress.

One win, as Anderson says, can change a lot. It can quieten the noise, buy time, and let a project breathe.

But if Newcastle walk off the pitch at Selhurst with another defeat, another porous display and another blunt attacking performance, those clips of Keegan’s 5-0 will feel less like a celebration and more like a taunt.

How long can a club live off memories when the present keeps asking harder questions?