logo

Who Could Succeed Michael Carrick as Manchester United Manager?

Michael Carrick is nearing the end of his patience as Manchester United's manager after a troubling streak of eight games without a win across all competitions. The latest setbacks—a 4-1 loss to Como in the Champions League followed by a 3-0 home defeat to Bournemouth—have only increased scrutiny on him. Fans left Old Trafford in large numbers during the Bournemouth match, reflecting the deep frustration.

While issues at United run deeper than just coaching, as defender Lisandro Martinez pointed out after a recent defeat to Atletico Madrid, criticism from club captain Bruno Fernandes regarding tactics and his benching against Bournemouth have put Carrick's position on shaky ground. The club is already considering alternatives should Carrick depart, following the exits of Erik ten Hag and Ruben Amorim under new minority owners Ineos.

In a pre-match press conference, Carrick stressed the values of sacrifice, humility, and hard work, emphasizing the responsibility of representing United. Despite this, the club must decide who can lead them forward amid a challenging season.

Potential Successors for Manchester United's Managerial Role

Eddie Howe

Currently available after stepping down from Newcastle United in the summer, Eddie Howe remains a top candidate. At 48, he revitalized Newcastle by rescuing them from relegation danger and guiding them to their best Premier League finish in twenty years, along with their first domestic trophy in seven decades. Known for an energetic and high-intensity style that earned Newcastle two Champions League qualifications, Howe's approach fits well with Old Trafford’s demands. He is the bookmakers' favorite for the role.

Fabian Hurzeler

At 33, Fabian Hurzeler has impressed by transforming Brighton into a competitive force this season. His tactical masterclass was clear in Brighton's 3-0 win over Arsenal and their 3-2 Carabao Cup victory over United at Old Trafford. Although Hurzeler is admired within United’s circles, Brighton would require a hefty compensation fee, which may not align with United's budget. Hurzeler has praised Carrick and reaffirmed his commitment to Brighton, underscoring the time and connection needed to build a lasting project.

"I’m fully focused on my job here... We have built this [together] over the years. You don’t take these things for granted. It’s a people business," Hurzeler said.

Julian Nagelsmann

Julian Nagelsmann, once linked with United following the dismissal of Ruben Amorim, remains a viable option. At 39, the former Bayern Munich and RB Leipzig coach would be interested in the challenge. United’s director of recruitment, Christopher Vivell, previously collaborated with Nagelsmann at Red Bull, potentially smoothing negotiations. His reputation as a tactical innovator continues despite Germany's early World Cup exit under his management.

Unai Emery

Unai Emery has excelled at Aston Villa, achieving Champions League qualification and ending their trophy drought with a Europa League win. Still under contract until 2029, Emery enjoys significant control at Villa Park and is focused on building a competitive squad. Moving to United would mean less control and a possible compensation cost that may exceed United’s financial plans.

Antonio Conte

The intense and demanding Antonio Conte could inject much-needed urgency and discipline. With a decorated career including Serie A titles with Juventus, Inter Milan, Napoli, and a Premier League crown with Chelsea, Conte has a history of quick turnarounds, like when he revived Tottenham five years ago. Yet, his outspoken nature and past clashes with club management pose risks. Recently, Conte denied rumors linking him closely to United, calling such reports speculative and stressing he will return to management only under the right conditions.

Conte stated: "There is currently no concrete basis for such assessments."

Cesc Fabregas

Former star midfielder Cesc Fabregas has gained attention for leading Como to their first Champions League appearance in just two years. Though his stock is rising, Fabregas seems committed to his current project, partly due to ownership stakes in the club. His future moves might include returning to a bigger club like Barcelona but for now, he appears patient.

Another Interim Appointment?

Manchester United have often turned to former players in interim roles during turbulent periods. Before Carrick, Under-18s manager Darren Fletcher oversaw a couple of games, while Ruud van Nistelrooy briefly managed between ten Hag's departure and Amorim's arrival. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer also experienced cycles of highs and lows as caretaker and full-time manager. United might again lean on familiar faces like Fletcher to steady the ship.