Pedri Faces Criticism After Barcelona's Defeats
Barcelona look for a way out of the storm. Two blows in a week – first Paris Saint-Germain in the Champions League, then Real Madrid at the Spotify Camp Nou – have dragged old doubts back into the light, and one name sits right at the centre of the debate: Pedri.
The squad has already turned the page publicly, talking up the trip to Deportivo Alavés and the meeting with Quique Sánchez Flores’ side. The noise around them, though, has not died down. It has only sharpened, and much of it is aimed at the midfielder once seen as the future of both Barcelona and Spain.
Pedri under the microscope
According to Sport, Pedri received some of the harshest criticism in the aftermath of those two defeats, with Cadena COPE’s Manolo Lama leading the discussion. Lama did not dance around the issue. For him, the problem is clear: Pedri’s body is not where it needs to be.
"To be a top-class player, you have to be at the peak of your physical level," Lama insisted, putting the spotlight not on talent, but on fitness. From there, his analysis cut straight into Pedri’s game.
"I have seen that he has a physical problem," he said. "When he suffers from a physical problem, his passing is not as accurate as it was before." The critique goes beyond a bad night or a dip in form. Lama described a player running on fumes, a midfielder who can no longer sustain the rhythm that once defined him.
Pedri, he added, "looks tired after the first ten minutes of the match," a damning line that hits at the heart of Barcelona’s late-game fade-outs. If your main organiser is drained early, the team’s structure suffers with him. The lack of energy in the closing stages suddenly has a face.
A mind slower than the legs
Lama then drew a parallel with one of La Liga’s rising talents, Pablo Barrios, to explain how fatigue erodes a player’s game. "When feelings of fatigue build up in a player, he loses his energy, and your mind no longer works at the same speed as your legs move, something that shows clearly on you," he said.
That is the picture he painted of Pedri right now: a player whose brain and body are out of sync, whose decisions arrive a fraction too late, whose passes lack their old precision because the base – physical sharpness – is missing.
The debate did not stop there. On the same COPE platform, Juanma Castaño, presenter of El Partidazo, brought up a key reference point: the World Cup. He reminded listeners that Pedri had already lost his starting place there, a warning sign that his status is not untouchable when the level rises and competition bites.
Club versus country
Castaño, though, drew a line between the national team and Barcelona. In his view, the dynamics at club level are different. He argued that the same scenario – Pedri losing his spot – is unlikely at Barça because, in general, the player delivers when called upon.
It is a subtle but important distinction. For Castaño, the current storm does not automatically translate into a demotion in Catalonia. The trust banked over the past seasons still counts, even if the last few weeks have opened uncomfortable questions about his condition and durability.
Bernardo Silva, the benchmark
Miguel Rico then closed the circle of criticism with a more specific comparison. For him, the key to understanding Pedri’s struggles against Real Madrid lies in a single name.
"Pedri's problem has a name and a surname, and it is Bernardo Silva, that player who has great experience and is strong when the situation demands it, as well as being a top-class footballer," Rico said.
In other words, when the stage demanded control, craft, and resilience, Bernardo Silva provided the complete package. Pedri, in that direct comparison, came up short. Not in talent, but in readiness – physical, mental, competitive.
Barcelona now head to Vitoria needing a response, not just a result. The team must show it can absorb two heavy blows and stand up again. Pedri, under the harshest spotlight of his young career, has to prove that this is a temporary slump, not the start of an uncomfortable new reality.






