Pochettino's Challenge at Manchester United: Reviving the Squad
Mauricio Pochettino has finally walked through the doors at Old Trafford, handed the keys to a listing Manchester United side and told to make it relevant again. Others have had that brief. Few have inherited a mess quite like this.
One win from 10 league games. Relegation zone. A squad frayed by injury, doubt and politics. Pochettino, long admired but twice overlooked in favour of Jose Mourinho and then Erik ten Hag, now arrives not as the bright young thing of English football, but as the experienced fixer with his reputation on the line.
The stars have aligned. The squad has not. That means clear winners and losers from day one.
Rashford: The Project Rebooted
Marcus Rashford has lived this cycle before: sidelined, reintegrated, then stuck in a fog. Michael Carrick brought him back in this summer, but the numbers have been brutal. Eight appearances, no goals, then a hip injury and more frustration for a 28-year-old who should be in his prime, not searching for himself.
Pochettino changes the equation.
The Argentine has already been flagged internally as someone who will “love” Rashford. Reports suggest he is a big admirer, the type of coach who will put an arm around him rather than freeze him out. That matters. Pochettino’s best work has often come with players who needed precisely that blend of hard edge and human touch.
His words during the 2022 World Cup still echo. “I’ve always liked him, I knew of his process because I was in England, but I think he’s a great player. He just needs the confidence and for himself to believe, to put him at the top level. The quality is there for him.”
That is not the language of a manager indifferent to a player’s fate. That is a manager who sees a project.
Rashford will get another clean slate. Another chance to be the face of a United attack rebuilt on energy, pressing and vertical running. If Pochettino is to drag United out of the mire, he will need a forward who can stretch the pitch and carry the burden. Rashford, more than anyone, stands to gain from this reset.
Shaw: One Last Chance With an Old Ally
Luke Shaw’s story at United has veered between promise and exasperation. Now 31, in the final year of his contract and worn down by a succession of injuries, he looked like the kind of player a new manager might quietly move on from.
Then the club chose Pochettino.
They know each other well. Over a decade ago at Southampton, Pochettino turned a young Shaw into one of the most coveted full-backs in the country. The Argentine adored his potential then, and while Shaw no longer glides up and down the flank with the same dynamism, Pochettino understands his game in a way few others do.
He knows what Shaw can and cannot do. That is crucial.
Rather than being discarded on reputation or age, Shaw is likely to be judged on what he can still offer. A fit Shaw, in a system that values structure and clear roles, could become a steadying presence rather than a symbol of the club’s drift.
Would another manager have taken that risk? Probably not. Under Pochettino, Shaw at least has the right to argue his case on the pitch. In a squad crying out for experience and reliability, that alone makes him a quiet winner.
Power Shift: Berrada and Wilcox Sidelined
If Carrick has paid the public price for United’s disastrous start, Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox are feeling the heat behind the scenes. Pochettino’s appointment has not strengthened their grip on the club. Quite the opposite.
This was not their hire.
Reports suggest the Glazer family pushed for Pochettino, while Wilcox preferred former Newcastle manager Eddie Howe as Carrick’s successor. That detail matters, because it hints at a power structure being redrawn above the dugout.
The Mail has gone further, claiming Pochettino will “not answer” to Berrada and Wilcox in the same way as Carrick and previous managers appointed under the Ineos-influenced regime. In a club where the manager has often been hemmed in by layers of football executives, that is a significant shift.
If Pochettino thrives, Berrada and Wilcox will struggle to claim the credit. If he asserts the level of authority suggested, their influence over recruitment and strategy may be diluted. They are no longer the all-powerful architects; they are executives watching a manager with his own mandate walk in above their heads.
Where that leaves them long term is unclear. But this is not their project anymore. It is his.
Bruno Fernandes: From Untouchable to Uncertain
On paper, Bruno Fernandes should be a Pochettino player. High work-rate, creative risk-taker, emotionally invested to the point of volatility. Pochettino even tried to sign him for Tottenham before his eventual move to Old Trafford. There is respect there.
Reality is less straightforward.
Fernandes arrives at this new era with his future in flux. Talks over a new deal have stalled. His form has dipped from the extraordinary heights of last season. The aura of being undroppable has faded. For the first time in years, United’s captain does not feel completely secure.
Pochettino could decide he is the man to build around, handing him the keys to a more coherent, structured attacking plan. But there is another path. At 32, with a contract running down, Fernandes is also one of the few assets who could still command a meaningful fee and help fund the defensive rebuild this squad so obviously needs.
His recent public criticism of United’s tactics did not land well with Carrick. It will land even less comfortably with Pochettino, especially if the Argentine does indeed wield more power than his predecessors. A manager with that level of authority does not have to tolerate dissent from anyone, however influential.
If Pochettino decides Fernandes is central to his vision, the Portuguese playmaker could yet flourish again. If not, he may find himself as the most high-profile casualty of a ruthless reset.
Pochettino has not come to Old Trafford to tinker. He has come to tear up what is failing and impose something sharper, harder and more demanding. Some will be revived. Some will be pushed aside.
United wanted a transformation. Now they must live with what that actually looks like.






