logo

Premier League Winners and Losers: Title Race Chaos

The Premier League returns from another international break with its usual chaos: form flipped on its head, narratives twisted, and a familiar cast of winners and losers emerging from the rubble.

Some are sprinting towards the title. Others are stumbling into old habits they swore they’d left behind.

Winners

Nottingham Forest

Forest look like a team that’s stopped flirting with the idea of progress and started committing to it. The trajectory is clear. They’re not just surviving; they’re heading for something far bigger. On their way to the title? It suddenly doesn’t sound like a punchline.

Brighton

If Brighton score first, you might as well start the engine and warm the car. Their last 10 Premier League wins have all come with clean sheets, built on 25 unanswered goals. They suffocate games, drain jeopardy, and turn the second half into a training exercise.

Pascal Gross glides through matches like he’s got a cheat code. Diego Gomez will shoot from anywhere outside the box and make it look like the most reasonable decision on the pitch. Luka Vuskovic, as long as everything unfolds in front of him and he isn’t asked to spin and chase, looks like the anchor of a defence that barely needs to sprint. Brighton score first, then OOP you into oblivion. The second-best team in the country are playing like it.

Noni Madueke

Noni Madueke is no longer just a subplot. He’s becoming one of the defining threads of this title defence.

Mikel Arteta called him “the best player in training in the last 10 days” before the October restart and said he had “no option” but to start him. A few weeks later, heading into the November break, the manager was talking about “a different Noni”. The evidence is brutal.

Nine games in 28 days for the champions. In that stretch, no player has been as influential. In the league alone, Madueke has directly delivered four extra points: the only goal against Nottingham Forest, then the shot that forced the decisive breakthrough against Hull.

Against Hull he was relentless. He took more shots than anyone else (four), won more duels than anyone else (eight), and had at least five more touches in the opposition box than any teammate. He completed six dribbles – as many as the rest of the players on the pitch combined. He didn’t just tilt the game. He tore it out of shape.

Across the division, no player is creating more chances per 90 minutes. It’s a small sample, yes, but this is exactly the elite, game-breaking wide forward Arsenal never signed in the summer. And he’s still overcomplicating chances at the end of sweeping team moves, which only underlines how much room there is to climb.

Snubbed by England, Madueke flew himself to Portugal to train, to sharpen, to turn “undesirable” into “undeniable”. Now he returns from another break, fuelled by that same fury – and, if you believe the whispers, by a pure hatred for Thomas Tuchel. Pity the full-backs in his path.

David Moyes

Say whatever you like about David Moyes – and people have been saying it for nearly 25 years – but the man knows how to build a Premier League centre-forward.

Thierno Barry is just the latest convert. Another striker repurposed and refined by Moyes, added to a list that stretches from Marko Arnautovic to Michail Antonio to Jarrod Bowen. At Everton, Nikica Jelavic and Beto both hit 16 league goals under him, despite sometimes playing as if they’d only just been introduced to the ball.

Barry’s brace against Coventry nudged him past James Beattie in Moyes’ personal Premier League scoring charts and into the orbit of Jermain Defoe and Duncan Ferguson on 15. He now sits two behind Jelavic and Beto in that peculiar leaderboard.

Moyes almost certainly believes Everton would have won the title in his first spell with Barry up front. The unnerving thing is that he might not be wrong.

Rodrigo Muniz

Rodrigo Muniz’s first Premier League goal since the opening day of last season came with a weight that went far beyond form or selection.

“Last season was really difficult for me because, now I can say it, but I had the surgery,” he revealed after the draw with Newcastle. “My wife was pregnant last season and, unfortunately, we lost the baby, but God is good all the time and now she’s pregnant again. The goal was for my baby, and I hope this season will be different than last season.”

A goal, a release, and a dedication that cut through the noise. You just hope Manchester United don’t find a way to trample over it.

Jules Ahoka

Before this season, Jules Ahoka had played 98 minutes of senior professional football. Ninety of those were at centre-half. That was the entire CV.

Sunderland still paid £8.6m for him in August. Since then, he has started five matches, scored in the Europa League and, against Chelsea, was effectively dropped into his full Premier League debut in the fourth minute, replacing the club captain against a midfield that cost £173m.

He didn’t blink. Ahoka finished as man of the match, making more defensive interventions than anyone else on the pitch: 14 combined tackles, interceptions, recoveries, clearances and headed clearances. Sunderland kept a clean sheet and their manager banked a vital win.

All this while other clubs spend fortunes on misfiring rebuilds. Manchester United’s chaotic midfield overhaul looks even more farcical when a teenager like Ahoka is plucked, polished and trusted so quickly elsewhere.

Liverpool

Liverpool are 18th in the home table, but top of the away one and the only side still unbeaten on the road. It’s an old fear whispered around Anfield: what if the stadium that once terrified opponents is now holding them back?

Away from home, they look liberated. At Anfield, something tightens.

Bournemouth

Bournemouth’s 2024 has been a case study in how to plan for the future without losing the present.

Within the same calendar year, they have set a new club record for their longest unbeaten run and matched their best sequence of consecutive wins. Those runs came under different managers, which says plenty about the structure above the dugout.

They’ve also become ruthless exploiters of errors. Evanilson has a knack for forcing mistakes, and Bournemouth have scored at least twice as many goals from opposition blunders as any other team in the league. The only regret? They faced Manchester City before Marco Rose pieced it all together and don’t meet them again until April.

Senne Lammens

There’s a code among goalkeepers, or so they say. Senne Lammens ripped it up. That wasn’t very Goalkeeper’s Union of him at all.

Losers

Crystal Palace

The charade is getting tired. Crystal Palace can dress it up however they like, but everyone knows where this ends. Stop pretending. Pick up the phone. Roy Hodgson is waiting.

Unai Emery

Unai Emery is a winner in one respect: Manchester United will now steer clear, which means he avoids the fate that has chewed up better managers than Michael Carrick. Emery and Aston Villa are stronger together than they would be apart.

But Old Trafford remains his personal haunted house. Ten visits, four different clubs, five different managers in the opposite dugout. He has led nine times: 0-1 on four occasions, 1-2 twice, 0-2 twice, 2-4 once. He has never won.

That isn’t a quirk anymore. It’s a curse.

Manchester City

The inflatable bananas and fancy dress don’t land quite the same when the football goes flat.

The new-manager bounce has faded, the siege mentality has cooled, and what’s left is a club in transition on the pitch and in stasis off it. City have started to resemble a collection of strangers, which is understandable given the turnover and tactical reset, but no less jarring.

It is one thing to stumble while evolving. It is another to do it under the shadow of systemic cheating charges, when the winning used to drown out the noise.

Manchester United

For two minutes and 46 seconds, Manchester United were bottom of the Premier League. In November. In their tenth game.

They escaped, as they so often do, in the dying embers. Fergie Time has become a broken clock that occasionally strikes the right hour, turning a likely defeat into a comeback win one week and a barely believable 4-4 draw the next.

The reality is uglier. This will almost certainly be their longest continuous spell in the relegation zone since at least October 1986, when it became obvious Ron Atkinson’s time was up. That moment has already come and gone with Michael Carrick, but the club clings to the illusion that another stoppage-time escape act means a corner has been turned.

It hasn’t. It’s the same infernal maze that has swallowed far bigger reputations for more than a decade.

Fun.

Rodrigo Bentancur

This was a Roberto De Zerbi failure first and foremost. That much needs to be said.

Still, Rodrigo Bentancur’s season for Spurs has bordered on the surreal. He has not been on the pitch for a single Tottenham goal in the league. Not one. In that time, they’ve conceded eight with him involved.

The sequence is almost comically cruel:

  • He starts against Aston Villa, comes off in the 84th minute at 3-0 down. Spurs then score twice in the closing stages.
  • He’s sent off at 1-0 down against Manchester United and somehow sparks a comeback from the dressing room.
  • Suspended for the next three matches. Spurs win all three, conceding just once.
  • Returns with a lively cameo against Leeds at 0-0, plays well, then still ends up assisting the winning goal – for Leeds.

Coincidence? Misfortune? An ancient curse? Whatever the cause, Spurs are consistently worse when Bentancur is on the pitch, and De Zerbi’s faith is starting to look like an indulgence he can’t afford.

Leeds

Beating Spurs helps. It always does. It was an excellent, fully earned, Farke-ing hard-fought win.

But ask any long-suffering Leeds fan and they’ll tell you the irritation doesn’t vanish just because the scoreboard looks right. They are still watching Tarik Muharemovic every week.

He’s written off as dreadful. Not physical enough. Not suited to the Premier League. Doesn’t even tip, apparently. Yet this “clogger” leads the division for clearances and headed clearances, both by a distance.

Leeds will roll their eyes and take one for the team. They’ll keep him. Begrudgingly.

Brentford

Three red cards in a season used to be the kind of thing Brentford sneered at other clubs for. Now they’re flirting with that line again.

Two dismissals for violent conduct in three games is a bad look at any level. There’s more sympathy for Igor Thiago than for Yehor Yarmoliuk, but both moments exposed a naivety Brentford should be long past.

Not since their first Premier League campaign have they collected as many as three reds. If they keep ignoring the warning signs, that number will climb – and so will the cost in points.

Hull

Hull’s last spell in the Premier League was a blur of heavy defeats. Only four of their 22 losses were by a single goal. This time, the margins are tighter, the scars less deep.

Their current winless run stands at nine games, but all three defeats so far have been either 1-0 or 2-1. That speaks to organisation, energy and resilience. They compete, they stay in games, they refuse to be the punchbag many predicted.

The problem is that resolve doesn’t change the fixture list. Brighton await after the break. That will test how far they’ve really come.

Newcastle

There are goals in this Newcastle squad. In total, 255 Premier League strikes between them. On paper, that reads like firepower.

Look closer and the picture blurs. Only two current players have ever reached double figures in a single top-flight season: Harvey Barnes, who did it for a relegated Leicester in 2022/23, and Yoane Wissa, whose final two campaigns at Brentford have proved painfully expensive for Newcastle.

Joelinton is third on their all-time Premier League scoring list with 24 goals spread over six seasons. Jacob Murphy, the hero against Fulham, has 23 in his ninth. Fifth on that chart? Fabian Schar.

Across Newcastle’s last 36 league games, only Will Osula (seven) has scored more than Anthony Gordon and Bruno Guimaraes (six each). Neither is a natural finisher, and the bulk of their goals were sold in the summer and never properly replaced, despite a transfer outlay north of £250m.

The numbers don’t lie. The goals left. The money went. The balance never came back.

Levi Colwill

Levi Colwill has entered the strange modern category of defender whose reputation grows in absentia.

Injury and Enzo Maresca’s public frustration last season helped cast him as a missing solution, a cure-all for Chelsea’s defensive chaos. Now he’s back, and Brian Brobbey is bullying him into a future appearance on some podcast, recalling through tears how that was his toughest opponent.

Performances like this won’t stop the inevitable Barcelona links. They do, though, underline how quickly one supposed answer to Chelsea’s problems can become another question.

Ipswich

Twenty-nine Premier League games without a clean sheet is not a quirk. It’s a crisis.

The last time Ipswich shut a top-flight opponent out, Christopher Nkunku led the line with Joao Felix in support. That belongs to a different era of their story.

The next chapter will be written soon enough. The only question is whether they can finally remember how to close a game down before it writes them out of the division altogether.