logo

Scott McTominay’s Next Move: Premier League Return or Reunion with Jose Mourinho at Real Madrid?

Scott McTominay has yet to finalize a new contract with Napoli, sparking widespread transfer speculation. Pat Nevin, a former Scotland international, shared his thoughts with GOAL about what could happen next for the Scotland midfielder, including a possible reunion with Jose Mourinho at Real Madrid or a return to the Premier League.

Leaving Manchester United for Italy

McTominay took a bold step in the summer of 2024 by leaving Manchester United, the club where he spent his entire career until then. After struggling to secure a defined role at Old Trafford, often playing as a holding midfielder, he transferred to Napoli for £26 million ($35 million). This move surprised many, especially since United’s midfield consistency issues seemed to call for a player like him.

Critics have questioned why United parted ways with a reliable homegrown talent who showed strong work ethic and versatility. Many argue the club underestimated his potential as a box-to-box midfielder.

Success in Serie A

At Napoli, McTominay has flourished in a more attacking role with freedom to advance forward. His first season in Serie A brought league title success and MVP honors. He also placed 18th in the 2025 Ballon d’Or rankings. His goal tally improved, reaching a personal best of 14 goals in a single campaign.

The passionate Napoli supporters have embraced McTominay and his partner, Cam Reading, affectionately known as the “Queen of Italy.” Despite recently dealing with personal health challenges, the 29-year-old is back in form during the 2026-27 season following World Cup appearances for Scotland. His current contract at Stadio Diego Armando Maradona has just over 18 months remaining.

What’s Next for McTominay?

With no new deal signed, Napoli faces a decision: sell McTominay now or risk losing him later without compensation. Interest from Barcelona has been mentioned before, and recent rumors suggest that Real Madrid is closely watching developments. Mourinho, now managing Real, was the one who gave McTominay his break at Manchester United.

A return to English football has also been suggested. When asked about McTominay’s future, Nevin told GOAL, “Such a brilliant question. It’s a tough one because there’s a lot of teams that would have him. I still, to this day, have no idea why Manchester United let him go, which is beyond me. I don’t think they knew his potential and his capabilities that Scotland actually allowed to burst free.I wouldn’t be shocked if he stayed at Napoli, but just about all the Italian teams would be interested in him because they love him, what he’s done there. Can he make the bigger jump a little bit higher? Do you know what? I guess just about anyone would take him.And the reason being, he’s a 10, he’s a six, he’s an eight, he’s a centre-back. I mean, you get four players. And they’re all good. So where do I see him playing? Here’s a weird one - anywhere he likes!”

Madrid or England: The Final Career Move?

McTominay remains tight-lipped about his future plans, focusing instead on his recovery after a minor operation for irregular heart rhythms. At 29, he likely has only one major transfer left in his career. The decision ahead involves either expanding his horizons—possibly moving to Spain—or settling down and continuing where he currently thrives, perhaps even completing a full circle in his football journey.