logo

VAR Controversies in Everton vs Coventry Match

Frank Lampard left Goodison Park shaking his head, beaten 3-1 on the scoreboard and, in his view, by the big calls as well.

Thierno Barry’s ruthless double and a late strike from Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall dragged Everton from behind to a comeback win on Friday night, cancelling out Yann Gboho’s opener and lifting David Moyes’ side up to fifth. Coventry, stuck in 16th, travelled home with more than just a defeat to digest.

They travelled home convinced VAR had abandoned them.

The hair pull that lit the fuse

The flashpoint arrived before the game truly found its rhythm.

As a high ball dropped into the Everton box, James Tarkowski grappled with Caleb Yirenkyi. The defender’s arm rose, fingers clearly in the Coventry forward’s hair, and Yirenkyi went down. Coventry players appealed in unison. Referee Stuart Attwell waved them away.

The laws were softened this season after a spate of red cards for hair pulling last year. Not every tug now means an automatic dismissal. Excessive force and intent are supposed to separate cynical acts from minor contact.

For Lampard, that distinction was irrelevant. Foul, not red, was his argument.

“They're saying it's not enough of a pull and I think it's a hard area to be in. What is a hair pull? You've decided it is but it's not enough,” he said. “I think the rules are fine. It's not a red card. I kind of get that… but I think if the rule remains that it's a foul so I felt it was a foul.”

On review, VAR Timothy Wood stayed out of it. The focus appeared to be on a possible handball by Tarkowski in the same phase rather than the clear movement of the arm into Yirenkyi’s hair. Coventry’s sense of injustice started there and never really left.

There is a strong case they should have had a penalty. For a spot-kick, Tarkowski’s actions only needed to amount to a foul, not violent conduct. If officials deemed it accidental, there was no offence. The replays suggested something more deliberate, something that merited a second look.

It never came.

Coventry strike, controversy follows

The visitors regrouped and, after the break, landed the first blow. Gboho finished smartly to give Coventry a deserved lead, the away end erupting in defiant noise after a disciplined display.

Within that same spell, though, Lampard felt another key decision slipped away.

Taiwo Awoniyi drove at Vitalii Mykolenko on the edge of the box and went down under contact. From Lampard’s vantage point, it was clear.

“Taiwo for me on the line of the box is a penalty. You've got to give the foul in real time anyway, the ref did let it go, and I felt it was a penalty,” he said.

The camera angle level with the 18-yard line told a different story. The clip looked to start outside the area. In that case, VAR has no power to intervene to award a free-kick; it can only step in for penalties. Even had the contact strayed onto the line, it would have been a marginal, soft intervention at best.

Coventry had the lead, but the game was sliding away from them in the grey areas.

Barry takes over, VAR stays silent

Then Barry seized control.

His first goal dragged Everton level, shifting the mood inside Goodison. His second, though, will live in Coventry heads for a long time.

As the ball bounced toward him, it appeared to brush Barry’s arm before he finished. The direction of the ball seemed to change just enough to raise suspicion. We have seen goals ruled out for less this season, not least Nottingham Forest’s disallowed effort against Tottenham in a similar handball scenario.

Lampard was adamant.

“The Barry one is handball, I've heard they are saying it didn't touch his hand but I've seen an angle where he has flicked it in with the final touch. VAR is there for that,” he said.

Wood again chose not to intervene. The explanation, by the book, is that there was no conclusive proof on the available angles that the ball definitely struck the arm in a punishable way. On the screen, though, there looked to be a subtle deviation that suggested contact.

This time, the benefit of doubt stayed with the attacker.

Moyes, unsurprisingly, backed his player.

“We've had plenty [of decisions] which have gone against us. It certainly doesn't hit his hand,” he insisted, while also taking aim at the hair-pull law. “The hair pull rule has changed so it would be a booking if it was but I still think it's ridiculous that rule is in the game. I can't understand why they don't fix this completely because I don't see it as a good rule at all.”

Barry’s brace flipped the game. Dewsbury-Hall’s late goal only deepened the wound.

Aggrieved and exposed

Strip away the emotion and the pattern is stark: three major VAR flashpoints, all breaking Everton’s way.

The hair pull on Yirenkyi? Coventry can justifiably feel they should have had a penalty. The Awoniyi incident? Likely outside the box, and beyond VAR’s reach. Barry’s second? The pictures hinted at handball, but the threshold for overturning the on-field decision was not met.

Two of the three left Coventry with a genuine grievance.

Lampard did not claim to be infallible. “I can't sit here and say I know everything and they should give all three of them,” he admitted. But he also knew what those calls meant for a team sitting 16th, trying to claw its way up a ruthless Premier League table.

“If one or two of them don't go our way… they would clearly change the game.”

On another night, with another set of interpretations, Coventry might have left Goodison with a point or more. Instead, they left with a manager questioning the framework that governs the sport and a squad wondering how many more times they can afford to be on the wrong side of the fine print.