logo

Life Under the Floodlights: Residents' Struggles at Junction Oval

At 10pm in Albert Park, the game isn’t on the field. It’s in the sky.

John should be in bed. Instead, he’s pacing the streets around 83 Queens Rd, pushed out of his own apartment by what he calls the “bright as hell” LED glare pouring off Junction Oval.

Seventeen floors up, Andrew reaches for sunglasses inside his own home. His apartment doesn’t dim when night falls; it detonates. “Like a Christmas tree,” he says. In photos, it looks like sunrise. In reality, it’s four 50-metre light towers turning his living room into a floodlit billboard.

Three levels below, James doesn’t need a scorecard to know when the cricket heats up. Strobing flashes slice through the edges of his blinds whenever there’s a catch or a celebration. His bedroom becomes a disco, then snaps back to full-beam white.

This is life on the boundary of Cricket Victoria’s Junction Oval. Not on match day, but on training nights, testing nights, and those evenings when residents say no one seems to be on the field at all.

A suburban stadium effect

The trouble began in August, when Cricket Victoria switched on its new quartet of 50-metre LED towers, built to bring women’s cricket to prime-time audiences.

On paper, the rules look tight. No use after 11pm for broadcast or streamed events, no later than 10pm for other events. An extra 30 minutes is allowed for patrons and staff to leave, but light levels in that window must drop below 10 lux. The towers can operate on just 45 days in a calendar year.

On the ground – or more accurately, in the apartments lining Queens Rd – it feels very different.

Residents say the lights have already been used for testing, matches and training sessions on almost half that annual quota in only a few months. They talk about evenings when the lights blaze with no visible activity on the oval. They point out that other, “less invasive” lighting is available, yet the stadium-scale LEDs keep coming on.

Locals saw this coming. Early last year, they launched a petition on change.org to stop the towers. More than 500 signatures later, the multimillion-dollar project still went ahead.

David met Goliath. Goliath won.

‘Living in a box’

James bought his place 12 years ago for one reason: the view over Albert Park. The lake, the trees, the city fringe skyline. Now, the moment the lights flick on, that view vanishes.

“As soon as they turn the lights on, my room becomes a box,” he says.

“They turn them on even though it’s daylight savings. They turn them on about 6pm and the amount of light that comes through the apartment, even with the blinds drawn… we’re effectively living in a box.”

Inside his home, glass is the enemy. Splashbacks, internal glass walls, polished surfaces – all of it bouncing the light around like a hall of mirrors.

“Then there’s the strobing lights when they catch a ball or something… we’ve got glass inside our apartment as well so it reflects off the splashback, the internal glass walls, it’s terrible.”

His family now eats dinner at opposite ends of the table just to dodge the glare.

For John, the impact is physical as well as psychological. He lives with a degenerative cornea and hyperthyroidism, both conditions that heighten his sensitivity to light.

“I end up getting really bad migraines and headaches,” he says. “So if I’m in my apartment, which is your home, your safe place where you feel secure, it just feels very violating having these lights on.”

He doesn’t try to fight it. He leaves.

“I literally do not want to be at home when the lights are on and I’ll get home at 11pm purely because the lights reflect off my TV into my bedroom… and I have zero interest in being at home when the lights are on.

“Even driving home along Queens Rd, as I’m pulling into the building, I need to have sun visors down in the car because (the lights) are blinding.”

He worries about people who are even more vulnerable.

“Anyone with photosensitive epilepsy could have an episode,” he says, pointing to the pyrotechnics and strobing that sometimes erupt without warning. “Who’s actually evaluated that risk? Or who’s taking that into consideration?”

Andrew had an option many don’t. He moved out.

He still owns his apartment and rents it out, but every return visit is a reminder of what’s been lost.

“I think it’s ruined the beauty of the area, even when I go back there now I just look at it and I’m taken away from the view and beauty of it all,” he says.

“But the lights, oh my god, it’s like living next to the MCG. I remember them going in and feeling so violated that we had no control over the four 50-metre-high lights being built right in front of our home.”

Residents say it’s not only private apartments at risk. They’re also worried about “vulnerable” people in a nearby homeless encampment, who have no blinds to pull down and nowhere else to go when the sky turns white.

‘On paper, none of this is happening’

For all the sleepless nights and taped-up blinds, the official record tells a different story.

An independent engineering audit, quietly submitted to the state government, declared the new towers “generally compliant” with Australian standards and requiring “no remedial measures”.

“No material exceedances attributable to the Junction Oval lighting installation were identified, and no remedial measures are considered necessary based on the assessment undertaken,” the Lucid Consulting report stated.

It did flag two locations on Lakeside Drive where light levels exceeded the 25 lux limit. The cause, according to the report, wasn’t the oval but pre-existing streetlights and “mild humidity” scattering light through the night air. Those exceedances were effectively waved away.

For residents, the report read like a technical shrug.

They say it ignores Queens Rd entirely – the strip where the bulk of affected high-rise apartments stand – and focuses on ground-level measurements, not the lived reality at eye level 10, 15 or 17 storeys up.

“The report makes no mention of Queens Rd, no mention of the apartment buildings within 50 to 200 metres of the towers and no mention of any measurement of line-of-sight intrusion into surrounding apartments,” James says.

At least eight formal complaints have been lodged with Cricket Victoria, Port Phillip Council and Parks Victoria. Residents say they’ve gone nowhere.

‘A bit of a farce’

From the start, locals felt the process was stacked against them.

They claim community consultation was minimal and poorly handled, with little of their feedback reflected in the final design. One information session with Cricket Victoria still rankles.

“There was no concern of what the broader community wanted,” John says.

He recalls notices about the meeting arriving on the day it was held, hand-delivered or dropped into letterboxes. “There were some very shady mannerisms,” he says.

Inside the session, frustration quickly boiled over.

“The question I asked at the meeting was how comfortable would you feel having a street light flash into your bedroom window,” John says.

“And they kept beating around the bush not giving a straight answer and I literally told them it’s a yes or no answer… we never got anywhere.

“We had that one consultation session where we said the lights need to be reduced in height and there was no sort of consultation that happened after it. It was sort of like, ‘this is what we’re doing. Either accept it or there’s nothing you can do about it’.”

Residents walked out describing the whole exercise as “a bit of a farce”.

Cricket Victoria tells a different story. A spokeswoman says community consultation began in March and April 2025, including direct mail notifications to neighbouring residents and an open forum at Junction Oval.

“Community members were also invited to sign up to a mailing list – Friends of Junction Oval – to receive relevant project updates,” she says.

Who’s actually in charge?

Legally, Cricket Victoria is playing within the lines.

The towers were approved via a special ministerial planning amendment that bypassed local council, setting the 45-day annual cap and the curfew conditions.

But when the question is not “Is it legal?” and instead “Who is responsible for the impact?”, the answers start to blur.

Port Phillip Council is the first to step back.

City of Port Phillip chief Chris Carroll says the towers sit on Crown land, managed by Parks Victoria, and were approved by the Victorian Government.

“While Council has no regulatory role, we have engaged in discussions with Cricket Victoria to advocate on behalf of our community and seek practical solutions to address concerns raised,” he says.

Local MP Nina Taylor says her office passed on objections when the project was first proposed.

“My office received a number of objections to the proposed Junction Oval Light Tower Installation in early 2025,” she says. “In every case, I forwarded the objection to Cricket Victoria and asked that their submission be registered as part of their community consultation process.”

She does not address the ongoing complaints.

Parks Victoria, the land manager for Albert Park Reserve, declines to comment publicly. It is understood to hold regular meetings with Cricket Victoria, where residents’ issues can be raised. For formal comment, it points to the Department of Transport and Planning.

The department says it has worked with Cricket Victoria and Port Phillip City Council “to support improved sporting infrastructure at Junction Oval”.

“Cricket Victoria has submitted an independent assessment of the lighting system, which we’re now reviewing,” a spokesman says.

Nobody, it seems, is eager to claim ownership of the glare flooding into people’s bedrooms.

Cricket Victoria’s stance

Cricket Victoria insists it is listening, and that the lights are being used within the strict framework set out in its approvals.

A spokeswoman says the lights have been used for training “on a small number of evenings” and remain inside the 45-nights-per-year cap.

“It is important for our male and female cricketers to be able to train under evening conditions like our competitors across the country,” she says.

The organisation also says it is working with local businesses on Fitzroy Street to ensure “the economic opportunities from increased attendances can be realised” and remains “committed to engaging constructively with our local community”.

It did not respond to specific questions about how it is managing complaints from residents at 83 Queens Rd.

A fight over how bright sport should shine

For now, the towers stay up, the lights stay on and the residents keep filing complaints and collecting evidence. They’re exploring what further action they can take to have the lights dimmed to a level they can live with.

They don’t deny the value of elite women’s cricket. They don’t want Junction Oval shut down. What they’re asking is simpler and more complicated at the same time: a balance between a national broadcast product and a neighbourhood’s right to the dark.

Because when the stadium lights go on and the cameras roll, the country sees a pristine outfield and a well-lit pitch.

It doesn’t see the people in Albert Park, eating dinner at opposite ends of the table, sunglasses on at 10pm, wondering how a suburban oval suddenly became a floodlit arena that never really goes to sleep.