Opportunity Slips Away for Patterson and Konstas in Sydney
Kurtis Patterson and Sam Konstas walked into Wednesday with opportunity in front of them and walked off with it slipping away.
On a day built for statement innings at Cricket Central in Sydney, the New South Wales pair missed a golden chance to hammer home their credentials as contenders to replace Marnus Labuschagne in Australia’s Test top order.
Flying start, brutal halt
For nine overs, it looked like a mismatch.
After NSW won the toss and chose to bat, Konstas and Ollie Davies tore into South Australia’s attack, rattling 81 runs in a blur of clean hitting and intent that left the Redbacks rattled.
Davies set the tone immediately, taking 17 from Wes Agar’s opening over. Konstas joined in with authority, crunching his first two balls of the morning through the covers for four. Both openers scored at a rate that made the fielders look like they were chasing shadows.
Davies reached his half-century from just 36 balls, South Australia’s plans in tatters and their bowlers searching for answers.
Then the rush of blood came.
First ball of the 10th over, Konstas charged down the pitch and tried to go over mid-off. He didn’t clear the infield. He picked out Nathan McSweeney, South Australia’s captain and, tellingly, another man eyeing Labuschagne’s spot in the Test XI this summer. Konstas was gone for 24 from 19 balls. NSW’s surge had its first crack.
The opening then became a collapse.
Patterson’s chance goes begging
Kurtis Patterson walked in with the script written for him. Set platform, fast outfield, a bowler under pressure. A day to remind the selectors why many still see him as the most natural fit at No.3 for Australia.
Instead, it turned into a nightmare.
Jordan Buckingham, having just removed Konstas, went again. Patterson, 33 and still fighting to add to the two Tests he played in 2019, flicked casually off his pads. It went straight to Jake Lehmann at backward square leg. Third ball, no score. A duck that will sting far more than the number suggests.
Coming off scores of 14 and nine in the previous Shield round against Tasmania, Patterson needed weight of runs, not more questions. By tea, his case for a recall felt noticeably weaker.
Davies tried to drag the innings back, but his counterpunch ended before lunch, dismissed by Ben Manenti for 70. Nic Maddinson, himself recently axed from the national set-up then recalled in controversial fashion, lashed a brisk 47 after being dropped from the first ball he faced. It was the kind of innings that thrills coaches and infuriates bowlers, but it never grew into the defining score he needed either.
NSW were eventually bundled out for just 204 before tea. The early fireworks had faded into frustration.
Buckingham, in his first Shield match of the season, walked off with his fifth five-wicket haul in first-class cricket and the game firmly in his grasp.
Weatherald responds, McSweeney falters
South Australia’s reply carried its own storyline.
Jake Weatherald, recently dropped from Test contention, answered in the way that matters most: with an unbeaten century. Where NSW’s top order lost their discipline after a rapid start, Weatherald dug in and rebuilt his credentials, stroke by stroke.
McSweeney, whose name also sits in that growing list of potential Labuschagne replacements, could not match him. He edged outside off for 16, never quite settling, never imposing himself the way a would-be Test No.3 must.
By stumps, South Australia were 5-162, the game evenly poised, the individual battles anything but.
Handscomb refuses to go away
In Melbourne, another familiar name surged back into the Test conversation.
Peter Handscomb, long tagged as a “nearly” man of Australian cricket, produced a chanceless 131 not out against Western Australia at the MCG. It was the sort of innings that forces selectors to keep your name in bold.
The Victorian right-hander, who recently toured India with Australia A, looked every bit the seasoned run-machine again. He stitched together two key partnerships: 53 with Ashley Chandrasinghe and an unbroken 74 with Blake Macdonald, guiding Victoria to 3-292 at stumps.
Handscomb admitted the runs hadn’t flowed this Shield season and that the India tour had yielded only modest returns. But he never felt out of form, just out of luck.
He spoke of going back to basics, doubling down on how he wanted to bat, and clearing his head. The result was a day where the ball seemed to find the middle of his bat and nothing else.
The 32-year-old made no secret of his ambitions: he still wants to play Test cricket for Australia, and he knows consistent Shield runs are his only argument.
He didn’t agree with the message sent by Nic Maddinson’s shock recall, but he refused to dwell. He has spoken with selector Tony Dodemaide, accepted the reasoning, and moved on in the only way that really counts in this debate: by making runs.
On the lingering sandpaper scandal, Handscomb shut the door quickly. He had, as he put it, enjoyed his day too much to wade into that fire again.
Labuschagne’s lean return
While others pressed their cases, Marnus Labuschagne’s own return to domestic cricket did little to shift the narrative around him.
Playing for Queensland, the Bulls captain looked sharp early, drilling the very first ball of the innings from Beau Webster through the covers for four. It was vintage Labuschagne: positive, precise, authoritative.
Then it stalled.
Across 36 balls, he never found the rope again. Eventually, he nicked off on a sixth-stump line for 12, a loose edge through to the keeper. For a player George Bailey has all but ruled out of the New Zealand series, it was another quiet day at a time he would rather be making noise.
His dismissal opened the door for Jack Clayton, another name suddenly very much in the frame to replace Labuschagne at No.3 this summer. Clayton settled, worked his way in, and alongside opener Hugo Burdon kept Queensland’s innings afloat.
After 50 overs, the Bulls sat at 2-131, Burdon unbeaten on 64 after bringing up his second first-class fifty, Clayton solid on 36. Both would fall later in the day, for 70 and 52 respectively, but they had done enough to hold the innings together.
Queensland closed at 5-195, the scoreboard modest, the subtext anything but.
Because this is where Australian cricket stands right now: a summer looming, a vacancy at No.3, and a carousel of contenders taking turns to impress or stumble.
Handscomb piles on runs. Weatherald responds. Clayton quietly builds. Patterson and Konstas blink when the spotlight hits. Labuschagne himself can’t land the punch he needs.
Someone will own that spot soon. The question is who will still be standing when the selectors finally make the call.






